1,090 thoughts on “Hawaii Visitors and Residents Whipsaw in 1,000 Comments”
John L
I’ve visited Hawaii over 40 times. I’ve picked Macadamia nuts off the ground on the big island, enjoyed the sunrise on Haleakala, surfed the north shore on Oahu and ziplined on Kauai. After 30 visits I realized I was only “taking” from the islands. It’s time to start giving back. For the last few years my wife and I have become vacation volunteers at the National Tropical Botanical Gardens. We’ve enjoyed every tourist activity Kauaiians have to offer. Now we give back half of our vacation time to support the island we love. We’re looking forward to coming back when the restrictions are lifted and the volunteer program restarts.
My husband and I have visited Oahu, Maui, Kauai, and the Big Island. Our favorite islands are Maui and Kauai and we would give both islands a “10” on friendliness. We normally stay in a condo, rent a vehicle and explore. We typically stay two to three weeks. We live in Florida and started visiting in 1986 when we lived in Virginia. We have always felt welcome and have respect for Hawaiians and their customs as well as an interest in your long and amazing history. My personal opinion re “friendliness” (we live in a Gulf Coast community economically dependent on tourism)is that it is very easy to welcome those who treat our beautiful city and it’s residents with respect. Too many make derogatory remarks re things that differ from their communities “up north” and leave trash wherever they go. So they may not experience open and welcoming attitudes when they are impatient and LOUD when visiting. I have observed the same behaviors while visiting your islands. It is why we typically rent a condo. Hawaii is truly our favorite state and vacation spot because it is hard to find a paradise as beautiful as where we live in Tarpon Springs, FL.
Visitors to the islands. First of all the current 14 day quar antine policy is intended to PREVENT ALL visitors from coming.
Yet an average of 125 per day have come since quarantine announced… over 4000 total. Obviously any visitor who has come to Hawaii during the quar antine period must be either not very smart or are very NON RISK AVERSE since to remain in place for 14 days without being able to go out of your hotel room ( Transient rentals are illegal at this time) would imply they intend to defy the quar antine…. there is no other explanation for such behavior. So therefore, yes, the locals are not happy with this kind of visitor and they are indeed a real healthier threat while Hawaii is actively trying to control increasing infection rates. Hawaii is uniquely suited to controlling this if it wishes to do so for its local population- we are an island and thus unlike other mainland states or countries its not possible to just drive in without various checks being made. I believe that people visiting Hawaii without a quar antine program will eventually have to demonstrate freedom from this along with an antibody test in form of a form filled out by a doctor at origin within 72 hours of flight and submitted to the health department prior to arrival. No form no entry allowed. As to “leg bracelets” we have the technology in hand to require each visitor to apply a Dept of Health location app on the cell phone and if no cell phone require an “ALOHA” bracelet which would also be able to monitor location… this all for contact tracing to control disease. All the nonsense of human rights violation go out the window as we are in a state of war if you haven’t noticed and tight controls must exist until this runs its course or there is a vac cine which then should be required for entry. Heck to bring our dogs into hawaii we have to pull blood titlres, get rabies shots and health certs and pre apply for entry. If visitors feel this is discourteous I suggest they go to Mexico( Narcos, kidnappings and the runs) or go to Florida onto their crowded beaches with all the college kids maintaining social distancing… By strictly trying to dampen the effects of this virus travellers will recognize how safe Hawaii really is
and there will be MORE PEOPLE WANTING TO VISIT THAN CAN SAFELY BE HANDLED out of respect for our local populations health… Long run such policy will bring back tourism but I do wonder… is 10 million a year overrunning our roads and beaches the correct number… maybe a little respite from such volumes is in order… maybe this is sending a signal not to crowd each other out so much…. It is up to the residents to say how many visitors is satisfactory, not some corporate travel company or corporate hotels or tourists who scream ” WHERE IS YOUR ALOHA FOR NOT ALLOWING US ENTRY ? Aloha is the visitor recognizing that we are trying to control this vi rus that kills members of our family and that this is our OHANA and please show respect accordingly
STAY WELL ALL and don’t succumb to commercial interests pushing tourism to come back before its time.. this is with us for 12-18 months and when we look back and have done the right job in controlling it we will have won this
war against it. If not, well, it will be easy to point to those who promoted early tourism without controls….
I second this emotion. I’ve been saying since the 14-day quar antine enactment that government officials are naive to think that the visitors will all comply. Don’t they realize that anyone traveling during this is obviously not a “team player”? They are the type of people who are propelled by cheap fares and selfish intentions. Realizing this, the quar antine requirement should have been more strict from the start so law enforcement wouldn’t have to waste their time chasing after these stubborn, selfish, reckless visitors. We locals actually cheer when we see a news item about a visitor being arrested. To all of you who cancelled trips here, THANK YOU!
We visit Kauai every year and have never experienced any hostility. We’re pretty much nice to everyone, locals as well as fellow vacationers, and find that most (not all) respond favorably to kindness. Of course, most of our interactions are with the resort staff, housekeepers, grounds people, as well as the staff in restaurants and shops, where money and employment status would come into play. We make it a point to talk with these folks, especially the housekeepers and grounds people, and just ask them how their day is going. We’ve found if we take a genuine interest in them, they will open up and be friendly in return. I’m sure that some visitors go to the islands and because they have spent a lot of money going there, they feel they are entitled. We’ve seen that actually. But I’m also wondering…. If the hostility others talk about might not be partly due to some transplants from the mainland, those who come with a lot of money and want to buy up this and that, change things to suit themselves, act like they own the place because they are now residents, basically being “Ugly Mainlanders” (vice “Ugly Americans”). But we’ll keep going to Kauai, at least until the island prices us out of our business, which is a topic for another discussion.
Aloha, My husband and I have been to Hawaii many times and always felt that people were very nice except for the last time in 2018 when we came to Kauai to renew or wedding vows on our 50th wedding anniversary. And then it was only a few times we ran into some who were sarcastic and cold. And even then, not sure if they were locals or visitors. We were both surprised to see the trash along the roads in 2018 when we were there. We also saw some people who disrespected the tape around the monk seals and crossed over to get close to the seals. Trash in the ocean is another thing we hadn’t seen before, so I can see why locals could get very frustrated with visitors who don’t care. They have taken the time and the precautions to keep their island clean and beautiful for visitors to enjoy but some visitors don’t reciprocate and assist in keeping the island clean and beautiful. I’m sorry to admit I’m a visitor to Hawaii as I love the island and always do my part in trying to keep it cleaner than I found it and just as beautiful as it has always been. Please don’t think all tourists are destructive and don’t abide by your standards in Hawaii! We try and I’m sure others do also. And by the same token, I would never think that all Hawaiians are rude and hate tourists. I hope to visit again sometime in the not too distant future and until then, Aloha!
I wrote some long comment but here is the short version. I have family on 3 islands and have been on countless trips. The more rural and further they can trace Hawaiian roots, the more they tend to hate white people and tourists. The funny thing is that most are a mix of the very thing they hate (Polynesian/White/Japanese/etc). I am not saying that their feelings aren’t justified but it can leave a bad taste in your mouth. I fly under the radar and do show respect for the people there. Even so, it’s sometimes very difficult to find authentic Aloha.
Thanks for putting this topic out there. This is definitely a hot button item on both sides. As you stated, this is a mutual respect type of issue which can quickly turn into a love-hate situation. The key to this lies in understanding each other’s point of view then working to avoid trampling on the other’s feelings.
Having been both a local and a visitor, I’ve tried to summarize the feelings of each group below:
HAWAIIAN LOCALS
Generally speaking, most locals realize that they live in a beautiful area and are willing to share that area, and their culture, with others. The locals understand that there are issues that come with this “arrangement” which includes traffic, crowding, high prices, etc. With that said, just like hosting someone in your home, locals expect a certain degree of decorum from any visitor. This includes littering, respecting the environment (including turtles & beaches), not overwhelming local resources (hospitals, shopping, etc). Most locals understand that this requires a delicate balance but at times, if they feel they are being disrespected, will respond with things like “Go back to where you came from, we don’t need you THAT much”.
VISITORS
Visitors to Hawaii are looking to trade some (some would say a LOT) of their hard-earned savings to be able to experience a piece of the magic that is Hawaii. To a previous post, if it were just the beaches, there are other beaches in other parts of the world that are less expensive. Visitors are seeking that Aloha spirit and the ability to experience that spirit in a way that is personal to them. Visitors feel disrespected when they are treated in something other than a welcoming manner. Unfortunately, the latest proposal by Hawaiian officials about putting ankle bracelets on visitors was a MAJOR stab at the heart to many visitors who often wonder just how “welcome” they really are. In the end the proposal was deemed to be too expensive so was not implemented but the damage had already been done to confirm the suspicions of the Visitors. When they feel they are being disrespected visitors will respond with things like “Fine, if we are not welcome then we will just take our tourist $$$ somewhere else and you can say goodbye to my $$$ and 23%+ of your local economy”.
If both locals and visitors can understand the others “hot buttons” and be proactive in trying to avoid offending the other, then we will all get along well together. If not, then we are all going to continue having feelings hurt and lashing out.
Using Rodney King’s quip of “Can’t we all just get along”, I think we can all take that to the next level of “Can’t we all just work together and have mutual respect for each other to avoid offending our host/source of livelihood?”.
Yes! love your comment. I would argue there are 2 classed of “locals”. Multi generational locals and new locals. Its the multi generational locals that tend to hate tourists.
Also, also these comments are forgetting that Hawaii is a STATE. Its part of America! That is something that most native Hawaiians despise.
Thanks for all of the info you provide. We were stationed at Pearl Harbor in the 60’s and have returned almost annually and many times twice a year. My wife taught school there in the 60’s and we were blessed to become friends with ‘locals’ on the faculty. Two locals took us to Molokai, slept on the beach, and taught us how to find and enjoy fresh Opihi. Tourism has grown dramatically over the years and with that come many changes that impact the locals…some good and some bad. My suggestion is to meet as many people as you can outside of ‘tourist environment’. Also, we stayed at The Coco Palms in ‘65, Princeville was a cattle farm and the Original Black Pot was a unique and great place for fresh fish and to have a cold Primo with local fishermen. Aloha and Mahalo for all the memories 🏝.
Hope all is safe to return in October.
I appreciate this forum. As a former kamaaina (Born and raised on Oahu) I now live in Portland, Oregon. The “conflict” between locals and tourists is definitely not new. Having talked to family who still live in The Islands, the general consensus is the continued tourism at record rates (10M a year)Hawaii’s aina is continually being ruined by high numbers of tourists who don’t respect the land or the resources. This influx has brought in a huge number of different visitors who simply visit because of low fares. As a former commentator stated, Hawaii is of course a very different state. At 10M visitors a year, it simply cannot withstand further erosion of land and culture. This continued degradation used to be unique to Oahu but currently extends to all the inhabited islands. I ask visitors to simply be mindful of this very unique and beautiful place. Visit the museums and historical sights and learn how Hawaii has become such a special place. Instead of renting a car which considerably adds to the traffic problems, use the public transit system which is excellent. Many attractions offer buses that stop at various hotels.
My love for Hawaii and its people runs very deep. Even after 30 years of being on the mainland, Hawaii is an integral part of me, Only kamaaina know this feeling. It never leaves you and guides your soul through life forever.
We have gone to Maui each summer for many years. We love the land, the climate, the people, the food and the culture. With that being said, culture, any culture, needs to be respected and celebrated. Here’s an analogy, if one was to attend a cultural celebration of another ethnicity, one would respect the culture and traditions of that ethnicity and act accordingly. It’s no different while in Hawaii, as everything is culturally related. When we go to Hawaii, we understand that we are visitors, and thus act accordingly.
Liken it to visiting someone’s home: One should show respect to the host and and his home while visiting. Tourists should be no different. I feel most are respectful, but as usual, it only takes those few rebels to ruin it for all.
My husband and family have been to our happy place of Kauai many many times, we have made friends of the residents there who we love! I totally support the shut down during this even though it will likely mean our trip will be cancelled. During a pan demic this must be done.
I am truly saddened by the general, seemingly widespread and pervasive anti-visitor sentiments I’ve heard so much lately. I understand how visitors can be overwhelming and wearisome, that’s the nature of a tourist destination whether that’s an island, a ski town, a safari resort, etc. There is a tradeoff. I love Hawaii so much and it hurts to hear how unwelcomed we are. It does affect the joy I feel toward visiting.
I agree with locals not wanting tourists in Hawaii. My husband and I have gone to Hawaii almost every year for the last 10 years…The aloha spirit is a farce. Most of the locals tolerate tourists unless they are getting paid to be nice to them. I cancelled our planned vacation in July because of the vi rus and mostly because I didn’t want to endure the hostility that I knew we would encounter. Hawaiians need tourists and if they don’t wake up and start being more hospitable, more and more Mainlanders will be going other places and not Hawaii. Although I love Kauai, I can do without the Hawaiian hostility.
We visit Hawaii every other year for 2 weeks.. Mainly Maui. I’ve been to other beach destinations, such as the Bahamas and Aruba. We’ve always felt like our hard earned dollars were better off being spent in America than elsewhere where tourists were being tolerated for their money. It’s been disheartening to see the bitter comments about tourists. We try to be good visitors and respectful of the culture.
As one who lives in Hawaii part time I have mixed feelings about your comments. At the moment I’m stuck on the mainland and do not wish to have my American rights stomped on by returning to my island and following the governor’s oppressive mandates.
Of course I understand the need to protect residents and minimize the number of infections. But with a minuscule total of 613 cases and 16 deaths (as of April 29) the draconian measures go beyond reason.
I do get the sense that those on the islands would prefer to keep tourists away during this time and into the future. Well, that’s certainly been achieved. But the economy is suffering and the worst is yet to come. Don’t expect the federal gravy train and free money to go on forever. And without the revenue from the outrageous taxes on pretty much everything tourists do (rooms, rental cars, etc), it won’t be long before the bloated local governments look elsewhere (i.e. YOUR taxes).
And what do you think will happen once flights resume? Although there are obviously many more people in Hawaii who have been exposed to the virus (and hopefully have anti bodies to protect them) than the statistics say, the percentage is not nearly enough to insure the so-called “herd immunity” needed. So cases will go up when flights and passengers are coming again. It is the nature of the pandemic. Flatten the curve or not, this beast must make its way through the population.
Hawaii cannot isolate itself indefinitely. I want to come home.
You can home anytime- 14 day quar antine. Same respect you would give a friend or relative if you travelled to the mainland to visit- stay away for enough time to ensure you aren’t the source of infection spread.
Its the Draconian measures that have proven successful in stopping a high rate of infection in Hawaii… the bug doesnt
care where you live or your climate- it wants to spread through the population.
Hawaii’s medical system is not equipped to handle a higher amount of infections.. certainly not equipped to handle
30,000 a day of visitors which is the high season number….
This shock will be good for Hawaii…government will have to restrict and take hair cuts, the beaches are quiet, the roads are less crowded, COSTCO still a zoo but well managed and we have gotten to know more neighbors via nightly outdoor cocktail hours than ever before …. its actually wonderful right now and we have delayed our trip back home to Colorado to enjoy the beauty of Hawaii.
Its no wonder people who live here year round or part time don’t really mind less tourism… its not so bad… stay on the mainland and there will more to enjoy for us that like the Rock the way it is….. meanwhile our local businesses are slowly going to open, but it will never be the same again and perhaps thats good…
TOURISM WILL BE THAT LAST ISSUE THAT THE STATE WILL ADDRESS and lets hope it does it correctly or it will undo all the sacrifice
Hell, you can always go to Georgia, they are wide open for business !
I really like the Monk seals and MOST visitors, like us, showed them respect and gave them space. HOWEVER, one “visitor” from the east coast of the U.S. thought that he knew better than everybody else. On a small sandy beach across from the Lawai Beach Resort in Kauai. a “mamma” seal was resting with her pup. The area was cordened off with yellow tape and signs not to enter. This person, with a big camera, decided that the warning and no entry signs were not meant for him, and crossed through the yellow tape to get a close-up picture of the seals. He wouldn’t listen to the others on the beach to stay away and to not disturb Mama and baby. When he was very close to them, “Mama” sprung into action (protecting her pup) and took a BIG chunk out of his behind. He was then yelling for help, but ALL of the other on the beach were laughing and clapping for what “mama” had done. Nobody would help him, BUT did call the local fire department to send an ambulance to take him to the hospital. Don’t mess with mama seals, especially if they have a baby with them !!!
We love Kauai. We have been there a dozen times. We read books about the history and people and are very respectful. And love the music and dance and culture. But we won’t go back again. Over the years we felt and saw a real dislike of tourist including us. The papers were full of locals saying they did not want tourist there and making it hard to rent cars for several weeks. We will find another place to love. It breaks my heart as I will alway love Kauai.
I’ve read some really hateful comments made on various forums about tourists, ironically made by a lot of recent transplants, but also Native Hawaiians. The comments are so mean spirited, nasty, and downright threateningly scary that, for the first time in my life, I’ve considered not going back to Hawaii. Coincidentally, the Hawaii South Park episode where Butters voyages to his “homeland” came on and I had to laugh. They nailed it. I live in San Diego, large population, huge tourism industry. They unloaded at least 3 contaminated cruise ships here. I’m not mad at it. I just hope the hateful comments are just frustrated bored people locked up at home and not a new social norm. I gently remind them that at some point y’all are going to want to or need to leave the island and that judgmental finger will then be pointed back at you. I’m hoping this isolation doesn’t divide us as a nation or as a planet. I’ve always felt nothing but aloha on the islands but not gonna lie, the general vibe of the Hawaiian people making comments about tourism situation is pretty scary.
I am a licensed healthcare professional. I have spent time and worked on both O’ahu and Kaua’i, more time on the latter. I came to help provide care to the local residents. Before I arrived, I made it a priority to learn how to pronounce the words, understand Hawaiian history, and be respectful of and familiar with the culture.
I, as a caucasian man, did not feel welcome at all. At best, the feeling was of being “tolerated”. At worst, the attitudes I experienced hearken back to the southern states during the 50s. The nepotism in practice on the smaller island helps ensure that the problem won’t go away without a top-down change in attitude.
I have absolutely no doubt that some visitors are disrespectful, demanding, rude, and insensitive to local attitudes and culture. I was not one of those, yet I did not witness any differentiation between those who make an effort to practice “when in Rome, do as the Romans do” and those who do not.
In no way do I claim that every Hawaiian local is negative, racist, or unwelcoming – The great majority are not, but those who are have a very strong presence, and it’s hard not to feel it.
The events of this year and the effect on tourism – and by default, the livelihood of nearly every island resident – should underscore the need for tourists to return in order for Hawaii to return to normalcy. The more welcome those tourists feel will directly influence whether they choose to return and bring their money to the island economy.
“The nepotism in practice on the smaller island helps ensure that the problem won’t go away without a top-down change in attitude”.
Favoring locals in employment insures people from the mainland don’t squeeze us off our islands.
There is room for improvement with a minority of the population wrt treating visitors as guests in our home.And as good guests in anyone’s home being rude and insensitive is not and should not be tolerated.
I love interacting with the Hawaiian people…..and I love learning about their history and customs. I love how their families are so important to them. My favorite pastime is snorkeling and I always try to respect the reefs and local sea creatures; sad to say unlike some tourists. When we come (like every 2 years), we try to see something different and experience the local culture. Love supporting the small local vendors, restaurants and stores. These are the things we come to Hawaii for…not the glitter and glamour of the large resorts. Kauai is our favorite island, but we enjoy visiting all of them. We were looking forward to being there this year…but sadly this may not come to pass.
I have news for everyone locals in Maui hate
All tourists and people from the mainland. I lived
There for 5 years and experienced it myself.
They will tell you to your face go back to California
Even though you are not from there. If you are a tourist
You may not see this although all employees at hotels
Are nice to you if you grease there hands with a tip
I always told locals there is more Aloha in the states then in Maui
Hey Rob, you are right, the locals who many by the way are also long term transplants from the mainland, don’t like to wait in line at restaurants or wait in line at the intersection or be locked out of beach and surf access by the tourists.
County officials are actually same way… they place extra taxes on non locals, tax the heck out of the tourists and supposedly think that the lower cost housing would magically come if the tourists left while at the same time they are trying to get rid of the transient rental program with idea that the houses that rent for 1500 a day will become available to locals working at McDonalds… Government in Hawaii ( and everywhere) really have no concept how economics work… well they are going to find out- people won’t come but for other reasons and hotels will get MORE expensive not less as many won’t survive with 50% or less occupancy rates… restaurants will fail with fewer visitors and more employees will be lost. Maui has got a 4-6 month reprieve while the super charged unemployment kicks in but after thats over there will be many people leaving the island because of lack of jobs and government will have to increase taxes ( how do they do that when property values are dropping ?) Basically Hawaii is screwed. Next movement will be not how to get rid of tourists but how do we get rid of incompetent and useless government workers who sap all business out off the islands? IGE says 20% pay cuts… not enough… get rid of 20% as well as not needed. Rail program will be a complete funding disaster that no one will use… and now Maui has to pay fines and build new sewage systems as they have been pumping treated waste water deep into the ground near the shore ( you get your water from the water lens in each island) and destroying offshore coral for last 30 years and like next 10-20 since it takes that long for water to percolate…. and should I remind you about the failed ferry boat experience and the ongoing failure in building the worlds largest telescope on Mauna Kea. Hawaii has so many disasters going for it
that actually, tourism is probably the smallest problem when put into proper perspective… GOOD LUCK we will all need it over the next few years- buckle up, its going to be a rough ride.
I think Rob K’s observations are right on the money. Certainly the “vibe” from “locals” is different on different islands–and in different parts of the same island. For example, you could spend a week in Honolulu and never once get a bad vibe from anyone local… because Honolulu is a crowded, modern, ruined place that is typically over-run with tourists–and the few locals that you might encounter there are getting paid to serve you–either in hotels or bars or restaurants or shops. So, that’s what’s EXPECTED there. But if you wander too far out of that area–and bump into some of the more hardcore locals… out toward Ewa Beach and all the way up the coast toward Waianae and Keawaula… your interactions can be dramatically different even on Oahu.
The population density on Maui is WAY lower than Oahu. And the locals there tend to be a lot more aggro towards tourists and non-natives in general. And, to be fair, their “way of life” is really under threat–if not already ruined–by throngs of honeymooners and other visitors. Ironically, it’s Maui’s generally unspoiled natural beauty and low-density that makes it so popular–and is thus causing its own destruction. If you’re a local and you live somewhere along Mana Road… and you have to wait in long lines of tourist traffic to get out and go to work and get your groceries and run your errands every day–that’s going to wear on you after a while. And if you’re a local and you want to take your family to the 7 Sacred Pools for the day and when you get there it is mobbed with white-skinned tourists–that’s going to wear on your after a while, too. It’s the death by a 1000 cuts. None of them are major / serious offenses. But when you can’t even afford to buy the cheapest house on your own island–because wealthy foreigners have driven up prices to astronomical levels–how could you NOT feel resentment about that? Or if the only jobs available to you are tourist related–or constructing expensive houses for rich white people–how could you NOT come to eventually despise those people?
So, the question isn’t whether or not MANY Hawaiians on ALL of the islands have a Love/Hate relationship with tourism. Because they do. And they should. The real question is: Should it matter to you as a visitor? Should you NOT come to Hawaii just because some if not all of the locals don’t want you to come? Should that be the deciding factor? Because I would venture that that Love/Hate relationship between locals and tourists exists EVERYWHERE in the world that tourists throng to.
In a “crisis”, people show their true colors very quickly. And for sure the locals on Maui were the first that I saw on the news protesting against tourism and having small rallies and carrying signs that all said some version of “Tourists, Stay Home!” That thin veil of civility disappears very quickly when you add fear and ignorance together in a situation like this. It has happened over the millennia and will happen until the end of time: Whenever there’s a problem or a crisis, the blame immediately gets shifted to the outsider–the “other”. This has happened over and over again globally and in Hawaii specifically–as waves of cheap foreign labor were brought here to work different booms–mainly in sugar. Every time there was disease or high unemployment or civil unrest, the fingers immediately started pointing toward the foreigners as the source of the problem(s). (Just look at the way America treated its Japanese and German-ancestored citizens during WWII.)
So, again, should you CARE if the locals really don’t want you in Hawaii? Is it going to AFFECT your vacation and your experience here? That’s really the question.
We have been spending our vacations every year for over 20 years in Hawaii. This year we had to cancel and everyone knows why. If you respect the culture the locals are amazing. If you disrespect good luck. We all know that Hawaii survives by tourism dollars, One thing we have to remember is Hawaii is not like the mainland, their hospitals are not the same size or equipped to handle such a disaster as what’s happening. If you put yourself in the shoes of locals you can only imagine how hard it is for them worrying not only about loved ones and family but for the first time having to cut off the hand that feeds them by stopping visitors. Everyone in the entire world is under tremendous pressure right now, everyone needs Aloha. This will pass, things will change but we will all overcome this at some point and enjoy Aloha again.
Much Mahalo to BeatofHawaii🤙🏻
We have gone to Kauai every year for the past 20 yrs. We have always been greeted with friendly people everywhere. As a matter if fact we and our children have developed wonderful relationships with local residents and look forward to seeing them.
terrific videos. when I visit, luckily I stay with friends and come for at least 2 weeks. I believe I am aware of the issues and do try to respect the people and the land. it is so important. thanks for your website…it provides a great deal of information. I visit Oahu and stay in kailua and on kauai in priceville area. I am fine with the Hanalei to See Beach restrictions…better for all than the way is used to be. I am on the side of treading lightly wherever I go. thanks you
These videos well represent the local/tourist dilemma. We live in a Colorado ski resort so like to think we have an understanding of tourism relations. Yes, we get tired of tourists in our town but are well aware of what happens to our local economy without tourists. A prime example is the recent early shut down of our ski season due to this. When we are in Kauai, we try to be vigilantly aware that we are visitors and must respect the local lands and customs. In the 4 years we’ve been going to Kauai, we have alway felt welcomed by the locals but we can see why they get upset as we have observed how disrespectful other tourists can be. It’s not that hard to coexist – be kind, friendly, respectful, patient and generous. Aloha spirit goes a long way!
Mahalo!
I have visited the majority of the Hawaiian islands for years – at least 25, and have felt welcomed at least 90% of the time. The other 10% was us attempting to fit in and join activities that were more aimed towards the locals. We had to cancel our trip in April this year, but are still hoping to get go to Hawaii before the year end. We go every year for at least two weeks.
Mahalo.
Thank- you for being brave enough to put this thoughtful question out there. I have been coming to the Islands since 1992. My reason is a love of the people, the culture and the natural beauty. If I were just looking for white sandy beaches and water activities I can find that here on the mainland. The Islands and the people claimed a piece of my heart that first visit and it has always felt like my soul is home. I have on just a few occasions felt the hostility against tourists. It has been very rare. About 97% of the time it is warm genuine aloha. Whether it is someone whose livelihood is tourism or a local Ohana enjoying family day on the beach. Going hey you should go check dis. I have been invited to a Japanese family’s home to spend New Years with them & learn of their hospitality, traditions & culture. Welcomed into local churches as though I was one of their church family etc. I always try to be respectful as well as clean litter at beaches etc. when I am there. I do think some islands there is more of an anger against tourists as they try to preserve the old style ways and we are perceived as a threat to that. I understand that, as I experienced Kauai long before the Kapaa traffic jam etc. With tourism comes growth & progress.
I do hope though as we are coming out of the first phase of this unknown pan demic that this would be a time that Hawaii can press the reset button. Hopefully there will be a way to develop jobs in the green energy fields, agriculture , craft brew businesses and even tiny home builders. These would be jobs developed in areas where the islands jobs are not totally dependent on the tourist dollars. These are jobs that would benefit locals with a dependable food supply, clean energy jobs that respect the land, and housing that not only employs local tradesmen but gives young people a chance at finding affordable housing so they do not have to leave home to make their way. I will return again someday when it is safe to travel. Thankful for the locals that welcome me and hoping that no one ever feels anger or hated while there. There’s enough aloha to go around.
I’m originally from’Oahu, currently living in Tucson,AZ AND trying to move to Hilo. I am of Hawaiian descent.
I’m sorry to hear about anybody having a bad experience about visiting Hawai’i in general. Some of us locals don’t get the fact that ALL the islands NEED tourism and THOSE are the ones who, not only make trouble for the tourists but, the locals as well.
I believe that, if you’re a tourist who’d like to visit Hawai’i, BEFORE you come you should read about our islands, our culture, our history and anything else that the islands offer. That way, not only will you enjoy the islands, you’ll be more respectful towards them and its people and be humble as well. MOST of the tourists who visit are just interested going to the beach and shopping, I feel like that those ones are the ones who DON’T care about our culture or its people and act ignorant by saying how WE are supposed to be “lucky” that they came TO the islands. THOSE kind of tourists make other tourists look bad, just like when we have ignorant locals telling the tourists to go back to where they came from, they make all the OTHER locals look bad as well.
So… when you guys want to go and visit, learn ALL you can learn about us AND our culture then, when you come and we SEE that you show respect for us and the ‘aina…THEN, I do believe that you WILL have a WONDERFUL experience!
Aloha🌺
My brother and his family live on the Big Island. We would love to come visit and I understand the fear about the vi rus. I told my brother that Hawaii should open up to all Hawaiian residents. Open up the beaches, the ice cream trucks, the food places. Keep visitors quar antined for the time being, but let the locals keep the economy going and let the locals enjoy Hawaii for themselves while they still can. Visitors will return and for most locals this “quar antine” time may be the most beautiful time they will remember. Like old Hawaii before the tourists. I have so much I want to say, and the one thing is that fear won’t keep you from dying, but fear will keep you from living. Aloha.
Aloha, I get most of my info from you guys. A appreciate you. Visited Kauai with my son with Autism back in 2018. It was our first time. My wife and daughter were in New York. Kauai is everything I thought Hawaii would be. I told my wife how great it was and we want to make it part of our next trip. Keep up the great work, BOH. Aloha.
Have not been to Hawaii in probably 5-6 years, but had intended to last year, but failed to get reservations I wanted. Unfortunately I am not one of those WEALTHY individuals that most natives appear to like better because they have more money to spend. I try and stay at affordable places and those seem to be few and far between. Now I think that the “Powers that be” have put some type of restrictions on individuals and others who own and try to rent out their additional properties that are forcing them to try and rent for longer periods of time, so maybe some blame should be placed there. Either way, my money is GREEN like all others and when the natives are not getting enough of it, maybe they will invite me back. Is it still sought out and visited by a lot of Asians? Maybe they would rather have them!!
I am in awe of Hawaiian lands, people and culture. When I visit, I see it as a gift for my soul. In all my trips since 1975, I have not encountered any negative comments, actions or feelings from locals. This Texan is looking forward to the honor for my next opportunity to embrace the beauty of the people and their islands. Aloha.
Maui is our happy place and has been for 40 years. We live in a resort town on the mainland and have a similar attitude by the locals during the high seasons.After the explosion of this, much blame was put on the tourists. It’s not fare to do so at all. We need the influx of visitors to help the economy and keep the locals working. Hopefully people can see this now and be more hospitable. This is a land we all have to share, respect it and people that manage it. Aloha
We’ve been coming to Hawaii as a couple and then as a family of three for so long. We love Hawaii and we love residents there.
As a visitor, you need to respect the rules and respect the people of Hawaii. But then again, we should always respect each other and be kind to each other. I want to come back to Hawaii more than anyone and to do so, visitors need to follow certain rules, protect environment and behave. I’m glad Hawaii said no to visitors during this time. Why no? They’re just doing so to protect their people and state. Everyone is doing so. Wouldn’t you want to protect your family and home from others if there’s an outbreak? Would you let any random people in? I don’t think so.
Just a bit more time and doors will be opened.
Until then, take care Hawaii and aloha.
Until then,
I am so saddened by this whole crisis. We have been going to Maui yearly, and have moved our trip to the end of a July, in hopes that the travel ban will be lifted and we can enjoy Hawai’i and all it’s splendor. We love the culture and locals and respect their feelings. I think the majority of tourists are kind and respectful and responsible.
I think there is a huge difference – and this should be distinguished in surveys – between locals and Hawaiians. If you live on Hawaii for 20 years you are probably considered a local, but you will never be Hawaiian. Most (native) Hawaiians probably dislike tourists (or better said tourism). I can see tourists can be seen as an invasion for them, using their land for leisure. For sure most tourists are aware how important the land is for Hawaiians, but as always, 1 bad happening overshadows a 1000 good ones. Great topic!
I get it. A blessing and a curse. I live in So. AZ the economy of which depends on winter tourism. Snowbirds if you will. The population increase taxes our infrastructure to the max. I so love it when the heat sends them home for five months. So we try to be polite guests when we visit you.
There was an outstanding front page story in last Sundays Star Advertiser. It summed up what is a growing sentiment that
as we come out of this pan demic we need to look at ways to protect the Aina and nurture a tourist industry that
is more focused on quality then quantity. We simply cannot support growth at any cost. It isn’t good for the residents and isn’t good for the Hawaii that visitors are coming here to experience.
Expect more of what Kauai did. There should be more user fees and restrictions that protect the environment, not less.
Ideally Hawaii would be a little less dependent on tourism and a leader in green industry innovation and jobs.
I was lucky enough to have a 3 week stay on Oahu this January. Stayed with my sister, who lives on the main military base. I did a lot of solo sight seeing. By far my favorite activity was snorkeling. I fell in love with the ocean and the sea creatures!
I found local residents to be mostly ambivalent, a kind of tourist fatigue, which I think is totally understandable. I did have a negative experience or two, which were upsetting. I also witnessed tourists behaving poorly, oblivious to those around them. Like anywhere with heavy tourism, rules to protect the natural resources are essential and education is key. Thanks for this dialogue.
As a frequent visitor to Hawaii, once or twice a year, I find most native Hawaiians to be rather “cool” toward visitors. They’re not rude or unpleasant, just very detached. On the other hand, people who have moved to Hawaii and now call it home, mainly former mainlanders, are often the most friendly,warm and welcoming.
I do not usually comment on these things, for some reason I am. I have been to Hawaii 3 times, coming from NY it is an expense trip. I have family on Kauai, and at one point my brother was stationed At Pearl Harbor. It is one of my favorite destinations, we were hoping to go this summer (unlikely now). I have never felt unwanted in Hawaii, most of my encounters have been very friendly. That being said, I live in a tourist destination, so I understand the feeling of the locals. They like the money tourism brings, but not the crowds and the disrespect for there home. As a result, I feel I may go out of my way to be respectful. I am also usually with my family that lives on the island. Given our current health pan demic, I am honestly suprised that Hawaii is letting in any visitors. If the rate of infection in Kauai, rose like it did in NY, the island simply would not have the hospital capacity needed. Personnally, I think it is irresponsible for people to be traveling to Hawaii now. As beautiful as it is, the beauty will still be there in 6 months. I guess I will end on, if you show respect, respect tends to be given in return.
Our family has been raised with the words, “Leave the world a little better than when you came.” We have seen great partnerships between mainland people and locals through interest and support of their local heritage. And, you’re right, just showing respect and interest goes a long way…
I’ve visited Hawaii over 40 times. I’ve picked Macadamia nuts off the ground on the big island, enjoyed the sunrise on Haleakala, surfed the north shore on Oahu and ziplined on Kauai. After 30 visits I realized I was only “taking” from the islands. It’s time to start giving back. For the last few years my wife and I have become vacation volunteers at the National Tropical Botanical Gardens. We’ve enjoyed every tourist activity Kauaiians have to offer. Now we give back half of our vacation time to support the island we love. We’re looking forward to coming back when the restrictions are lifted and the volunteer program restarts.
My husband and I have visited Oahu, Maui, Kauai, and the Big Island. Our favorite islands are Maui and Kauai and we would give both islands a “10” on friendliness. We normally stay in a condo, rent a vehicle and explore. We typically stay two to three weeks. We live in Florida and started visiting in 1986 when we lived in Virginia. We have always felt welcome and have respect for Hawaiians and their customs as well as an interest in your long and amazing history. My personal opinion re “friendliness” (we live in a Gulf Coast community economically dependent on tourism)is that it is very easy to welcome those who treat our beautiful city and it’s residents with respect. Too many make derogatory remarks re things that differ from their communities “up north” and leave trash wherever they go. So they may not experience open and welcoming attitudes when they are impatient and LOUD when visiting. I have observed the same behaviors while visiting your islands. It is why we typically rent a condo. Hawaii is truly our favorite state and vacation spot because it is hard to find a paradise as beautiful as where we live in Tarpon Springs, FL.
Visitors to the islands. First of all the current 14 day quar antine policy is intended to PREVENT ALL visitors from coming.
Yet an average of 125 per day have come since quarantine announced… over 4000 total. Obviously any visitor who has come to Hawaii during the quar antine period must be either not very smart or are very NON RISK AVERSE since to remain in place for 14 days without being able to go out of your hotel room ( Transient rentals are illegal at this time) would imply they intend to defy the quar antine…. there is no other explanation for such behavior. So therefore, yes, the locals are not happy with this kind of visitor and they are indeed a real healthier threat while Hawaii is actively trying to control increasing infection rates. Hawaii is uniquely suited to controlling this if it wishes to do so for its local population- we are an island and thus unlike other mainland states or countries its not possible to just drive in without various checks being made. I believe that people visiting Hawaii without a quar antine program will eventually have to demonstrate freedom from this along with an antibody test in form of a form filled out by a doctor at origin within 72 hours of flight and submitted to the health department prior to arrival. No form no entry allowed. As to “leg bracelets” we have the technology in hand to require each visitor to apply a Dept of Health location app on the cell phone and if no cell phone require an “ALOHA” bracelet which would also be able to monitor location… this all for contact tracing to control disease. All the nonsense of human rights violation go out the window as we are in a state of war if you haven’t noticed and tight controls must exist until this runs its course or there is a vac cine which then should be required for entry. Heck to bring our dogs into hawaii we have to pull blood titlres, get rabies shots and health certs and pre apply for entry. If visitors feel this is discourteous I suggest they go to Mexico( Narcos, kidnappings and the runs) or go to Florida onto their crowded beaches with all the college kids maintaining social distancing… By strictly trying to dampen the effects of this virus travellers will recognize how safe Hawaii really is
and there will be MORE PEOPLE WANTING TO VISIT THAN CAN SAFELY BE HANDLED out of respect for our local populations health… Long run such policy will bring back tourism but I do wonder… is 10 million a year overrunning our roads and beaches the correct number… maybe a little respite from such volumes is in order… maybe this is sending a signal not to crowd each other out so much…. It is up to the residents to say how many visitors is satisfactory, not some corporate travel company or corporate hotels or tourists who scream ” WHERE IS YOUR ALOHA FOR NOT ALLOWING US ENTRY ? Aloha is the visitor recognizing that we are trying to control this vi rus that kills members of our family and that this is our OHANA and please show respect accordingly
STAY WELL ALL and don’t succumb to commercial interests pushing tourism to come back before its time.. this is with us for 12-18 months and when we look back and have done the right job in controlling it we will have won this
war against it. If not, well, it will be easy to point to those who promoted early tourism without controls….
I second this emotion. I’ve been saying since the 14-day quar antine enactment that government officials are naive to think that the visitors will all comply. Don’t they realize that anyone traveling during this is obviously not a “team player”? They are the type of people who are propelled by cheap fares and selfish intentions. Realizing this, the quar antine requirement should have been more strict from the start so law enforcement wouldn’t have to waste their time chasing after these stubborn, selfish, reckless visitors. We locals actually cheer when we see a news item about a visitor being arrested. To all of you who cancelled trips here, THANK YOU!
We visit Kauai every year and have never experienced any hostility. We’re pretty much nice to everyone, locals as well as fellow vacationers, and find that most (not all) respond favorably to kindness. Of course, most of our interactions are with the resort staff, housekeepers, grounds people, as well as the staff in restaurants and shops, where money and employment status would come into play. We make it a point to talk with these folks, especially the housekeepers and grounds people, and just ask them how their day is going. We’ve found if we take a genuine interest in them, they will open up and be friendly in return. I’m sure that some visitors go to the islands and because they have spent a lot of money going there, they feel they are entitled. We’ve seen that actually. But I’m also wondering…. If the hostility others talk about might not be partly due to some transplants from the mainland, those who come with a lot of money and want to buy up this and that, change things to suit themselves, act like they own the place because they are now residents, basically being “Ugly Mainlanders” (vice “Ugly Americans”). But we’ll keep going to Kauai, at least until the island prices us out of our business, which is a topic for another discussion.
Aloha, My husband and I have been to Hawaii many times and always felt that people were very nice except for the last time in 2018 when we came to Kauai to renew or wedding vows on our 50th wedding anniversary. And then it was only a few times we ran into some who were sarcastic and cold. And even then, not sure if they were locals or visitors. We were both surprised to see the trash along the roads in 2018 when we were there. We also saw some people who disrespected the tape around the monk seals and crossed over to get close to the seals. Trash in the ocean is another thing we hadn’t seen before, so I can see why locals could get very frustrated with visitors who don’t care. They have taken the time and the precautions to keep their island clean and beautiful for visitors to enjoy but some visitors don’t reciprocate and assist in keeping the island clean and beautiful. I’m sorry to admit I’m a visitor to Hawaii as I love the island and always do my part in trying to keep it cleaner than I found it and just as beautiful as it has always been. Please don’t think all tourists are destructive and don’t abide by your standards in Hawaii! We try and I’m sure others do also. And by the same token, I would never think that all Hawaiians are rude and hate tourists. I hope to visit again sometime in the not too distant future and until then, Aloha!
Hi Pam.
Thanks.
Aloha.
I wrote some long comment but here is the short version. I have family on 3 islands and have been on countless trips. The more rural and further they can trace Hawaiian roots, the more they tend to hate white people and tourists. The funny thing is that most are a mix of the very thing they hate (Polynesian/White/Japanese/etc). I am not saying that their feelings aren’t justified but it can leave a bad taste in your mouth. I fly under the radar and do show respect for the people there. Even so, it’s sometimes very difficult to find authentic Aloha.
Thanks for putting this topic out there. This is definitely a hot button item on both sides. As you stated, this is a mutual respect type of issue which can quickly turn into a love-hate situation. The key to this lies in understanding each other’s point of view then working to avoid trampling on the other’s feelings.
Having been both a local and a visitor, I’ve tried to summarize the feelings of each group below:
HAWAIIAN LOCALS
Generally speaking, most locals realize that they live in a beautiful area and are willing to share that area, and their culture, with others. The locals understand that there are issues that come with this “arrangement” which includes traffic, crowding, high prices, etc. With that said, just like hosting someone in your home, locals expect a certain degree of decorum from any visitor. This includes littering, respecting the environment (including turtles & beaches), not overwhelming local resources (hospitals, shopping, etc). Most locals understand that this requires a delicate balance but at times, if they feel they are being disrespected, will respond with things like “Go back to where you came from, we don’t need you THAT much”.
VISITORS
Visitors to Hawaii are looking to trade some (some would say a LOT) of their hard-earned savings to be able to experience a piece of the magic that is Hawaii. To a previous post, if it were just the beaches, there are other beaches in other parts of the world that are less expensive. Visitors are seeking that Aloha spirit and the ability to experience that spirit in a way that is personal to them. Visitors feel disrespected when they are treated in something other than a welcoming manner. Unfortunately, the latest proposal by Hawaiian officials about putting ankle bracelets on visitors was a MAJOR stab at the heart to many visitors who often wonder just how “welcome” they really are. In the end the proposal was deemed to be too expensive so was not implemented but the damage had already been done to confirm the suspicions of the Visitors. When they feel they are being disrespected visitors will respond with things like “Fine, if we are not welcome then we will just take our tourist $$$ somewhere else and you can say goodbye to my $$$ and 23%+ of your local economy”.
If both locals and visitors can understand the others “hot buttons” and be proactive in trying to avoid offending the other, then we will all get along well together. If not, then we are all going to continue having feelings hurt and lashing out.
Using Rodney King’s quip of “Can’t we all just get along”, I think we can all take that to the next level of “Can’t we all just work together and have mutual respect for each other to avoid offending our host/source of livelihood?”.
Hi Bob.
Thanks for your comment.
Aloha.
Yes! love your comment. I would argue there are 2 classed of “locals”. Multi generational locals and new locals. Its the multi generational locals that tend to hate tourists.
Also, also these comments are forgetting that Hawaii is a STATE. Its part of America! That is something that most native Hawaiians despise.
Thanks for all of the info you provide. We were stationed at Pearl Harbor in the 60’s and have returned almost annually and many times twice a year. My wife taught school there in the 60’s and we were blessed to become friends with ‘locals’ on the faculty. Two locals took us to Molokai, slept on the beach, and taught us how to find and enjoy fresh Opihi. Tourism has grown dramatically over the years and with that come many changes that impact the locals…some good and some bad. My suggestion is to meet as many people as you can outside of ‘tourist environment’. Also, we stayed at The Coco Palms in ‘65, Princeville was a cattle farm and the Original Black Pot was a unique and great place for fresh fish and to have a cold Primo with local fishermen. Aloha and Mahalo for all the memories 🏝.
Hope all is safe to return in October.
Hi Jim.
Thank you.
Aloha.
I appreciate this forum. As a former kamaaina (Born and raised on Oahu) I now live in Portland, Oregon. The “conflict” between locals and tourists is definitely not new. Having talked to family who still live in The Islands, the general consensus is the continued tourism at record rates (10M a year)Hawaii’s aina is continually being ruined by high numbers of tourists who don’t respect the land or the resources. This influx has brought in a huge number of different visitors who simply visit because of low fares. As a former commentator stated, Hawaii is of course a very different state. At 10M visitors a year, it simply cannot withstand further erosion of land and culture. This continued degradation used to be unique to Oahu but currently extends to all the inhabited islands. I ask visitors to simply be mindful of this very unique and beautiful place. Visit the museums and historical sights and learn how Hawaii has become such a special place. Instead of renting a car which considerably adds to the traffic problems, use the public transit system which is excellent. Many attractions offer buses that stop at various hotels.
My love for Hawaii and its people runs very deep. Even after 30 years of being on the mainland, Hawaii is an integral part of me, Only kamaaina know this feeling. It never leaves you and guides your soul through life forever.
Thank you for letting me comment.
Hi Maleko.
Thank you for all your comments.
Aloha.
We have gone to Maui each summer for many years. We love the land, the climate, the people, the food and the culture. With that being said, culture, any culture, needs to be respected and celebrated. Here’s an analogy, if one was to attend a cultural celebration of another ethnicity, one would respect the culture and traditions of that ethnicity and act accordingly. It’s no different while in Hawaii, as everything is culturally related. When we go to Hawaii, we understand that we are visitors, and thus act accordingly.
Liken it to visiting someone’s home: One should show respect to the host and and his home while visiting. Tourists should be no different. I feel most are respectful, but as usual, it only takes those few rebels to ruin it for all.
My husband and family have been to our happy place of Kauai many many times, we have made friends of the residents there who we love! I totally support the shut down during this even though it will likely mean our trip will be cancelled. During a pan demic this must be done.
I am truly saddened by the general, seemingly widespread and pervasive anti-visitor sentiments I’ve heard so much lately. I understand how visitors can be overwhelming and wearisome, that’s the nature of a tourist destination whether that’s an island, a ski town, a safari resort, etc. There is a tradeoff. I love Hawaii so much and it hurts to hear how unwelcomed we are. It does affect the joy I feel toward visiting.
I agree with locals not wanting tourists in Hawaii. My husband and I have gone to Hawaii almost every year for the last 10 years…The aloha spirit is a farce. Most of the locals tolerate tourists unless they are getting paid to be nice to them. I cancelled our planned vacation in July because of the vi rus and mostly because I didn’t want to endure the hostility that I knew we would encounter. Hawaiians need tourists and if they don’t wake up and start being more hospitable, more and more Mainlanders will be going other places and not Hawaii. Although I love Kauai, I can do without the Hawaiian hostility.
We visit Hawaii every other year for 2 weeks.. Mainly Maui. I’ve been to other beach destinations, such as the Bahamas and Aruba. We’ve always felt like our hard earned dollars were better off being spent in America than elsewhere where tourists were being tolerated for their money. It’s been disheartening to see the bitter comments about tourists. We try to be good visitors and respectful of the culture.
As one who lives in Hawaii part time I have mixed feelings about your comments. At the moment I’m stuck on the mainland and do not wish to have my American rights stomped on by returning to my island and following the governor’s oppressive mandates.
Of course I understand the need to protect residents and minimize the number of infections. But with a minuscule total of 613 cases and 16 deaths (as of April 29) the draconian measures go beyond reason.
I do get the sense that those on the islands would prefer to keep tourists away during this time and into the future. Well, that’s certainly been achieved. But the economy is suffering and the worst is yet to come. Don’t expect the federal gravy train and free money to go on forever. And without the revenue from the outrageous taxes on pretty much everything tourists do (rooms, rental cars, etc), it won’t be long before the bloated local governments look elsewhere (i.e. YOUR taxes).
And what do you think will happen once flights resume? Although there are obviously many more people in Hawaii who have been exposed to the virus (and hopefully have anti bodies to protect them) than the statistics say, the percentage is not nearly enough to insure the so-called “herd immunity” needed. So cases will go up when flights and passengers are coming again. It is the nature of the pandemic. Flatten the curve or not, this beast must make its way through the population.
Hawaii cannot isolate itself indefinitely. I want to come home.
You can home anytime- 14 day quar antine. Same respect you would give a friend or relative if you travelled to the mainland to visit- stay away for enough time to ensure you aren’t the source of infection spread.
Its the Draconian measures that have proven successful in stopping a high rate of infection in Hawaii… the bug doesnt
care where you live or your climate- it wants to spread through the population.
Hawaii’s medical system is not equipped to handle a higher amount of infections.. certainly not equipped to handle
30,000 a day of visitors which is the high season number….
This shock will be good for Hawaii…government will have to restrict and take hair cuts, the beaches are quiet, the roads are less crowded, COSTCO still a zoo but well managed and we have gotten to know more neighbors via nightly outdoor cocktail hours than ever before …. its actually wonderful right now and we have delayed our trip back home to Colorado to enjoy the beauty of Hawaii.
Its no wonder people who live here year round or part time don’t really mind less tourism… its not so bad… stay on the mainland and there will more to enjoy for us that like the Rock the way it is….. meanwhile our local businesses are slowly going to open, but it will never be the same again and perhaps thats good…
TOURISM WILL BE THAT LAST ISSUE THAT THE STATE WILL ADDRESS and lets hope it does it correctly or it will undo all the sacrifice
Hell, you can always go to Georgia, they are wide open for business !
I really like the Monk seals and MOST visitors, like us, showed them respect and gave them space. HOWEVER, one “visitor” from the east coast of the U.S. thought that he knew better than everybody else. On a small sandy beach across from the Lawai Beach Resort in Kauai. a “mamma” seal was resting with her pup. The area was cordened off with yellow tape and signs not to enter. This person, with a big camera, decided that the warning and no entry signs were not meant for him, and crossed through the yellow tape to get a close-up picture of the seals. He wouldn’t listen to the others on the beach to stay away and to not disturb Mama and baby. When he was very close to them, “Mama” sprung into action (protecting her pup) and took a BIG chunk out of his behind. He was then yelling for help, but ALL of the other on the beach were laughing and clapping for what “mama” had done. Nobody would help him, BUT did call the local fire department to send an ambulance to take him to the hospital. Don’t mess with mama seals, especially if they have a baby with them !!!
Tony
He got what he deserved. Although tourists like him are small in numbers, their impact is big.
You GO GIRL!
Let’s hear it for the mama monk seal! 👐
We love Kauai. We have been there a dozen times. We read books about the history and people and are very respectful. And love the music and dance and culture. But we won’t go back again. Over the years we felt and saw a real dislike of tourist including us. The papers were full of locals saying they did not want tourist there and making it hard to rent cars for several weeks. We will find another place to love. It breaks my heart as I will alway love Kauai.
I’ve read some really hateful comments made on various forums about tourists, ironically made by a lot of recent transplants, but also Native Hawaiians. The comments are so mean spirited, nasty, and downright threateningly scary that, for the first time in my life, I’ve considered not going back to Hawaii. Coincidentally, the Hawaii South Park episode where Butters voyages to his “homeland” came on and I had to laugh. They nailed it. I live in San Diego, large population, huge tourism industry. They unloaded at least 3 contaminated cruise ships here. I’m not mad at it. I just hope the hateful comments are just frustrated bored people locked up at home and not a new social norm. I gently remind them that at some point y’all are going to want to or need to leave the island and that judgmental finger will then be pointed back at you. I’m hoping this isolation doesn’t divide us as a nation or as a planet. I’ve always felt nothing but aloha on the islands but not gonna lie, the general vibe of the Hawaiian people making comments about tourism situation is pretty scary.
I am a licensed healthcare professional. I have spent time and worked on both O’ahu and Kaua’i, more time on the latter. I came to help provide care to the local residents. Before I arrived, I made it a priority to learn how to pronounce the words, understand Hawaiian history, and be respectful of and familiar with the culture.
I, as a caucasian man, did not feel welcome at all. At best, the feeling was of being “tolerated”. At worst, the attitudes I experienced hearken back to the southern states during the 50s. The nepotism in practice on the smaller island helps ensure that the problem won’t go away without a top-down change in attitude.
I have absolutely no doubt that some visitors are disrespectful, demanding, rude, and insensitive to local attitudes and culture. I was not one of those, yet I did not witness any differentiation between those who make an effort to practice “when in Rome, do as the Romans do” and those who do not.
In no way do I claim that every Hawaiian local is negative, racist, or unwelcoming – The great majority are not, but those who are have a very strong presence, and it’s hard not to feel it.
The events of this year and the effect on tourism – and by default, the livelihood of nearly every island resident – should underscore the need for tourists to return in order for Hawaii to return to normalcy. The more welcome those tourists feel will directly influence whether they choose to return and bring their money to the island economy.
“The nepotism in practice on the smaller island helps ensure that the problem won’t go away without a top-down change in attitude”.
Favoring locals in employment insures people from the mainland don’t squeeze us off our islands.
There is room for improvement with a minority of the population wrt treating visitors as guests in our home.And as good guests in anyone’s home being rude and insensitive is not and should not be tolerated.
I love interacting with the Hawaiian people…..and I love learning about their history and customs. I love how their families are so important to them. My favorite pastime is snorkeling and I always try to respect the reefs and local sea creatures; sad to say unlike some tourists. When we come (like every 2 years), we try to see something different and experience the local culture. Love supporting the small local vendors, restaurants and stores. These are the things we come to Hawaii for…not the glitter and glamour of the large resorts. Kauai is our favorite island, but we enjoy visiting all of them. We were looking forward to being there this year…but sadly this may not come to pass.
I have news for everyone locals in Maui hate
All tourists and people from the mainland. I lived
There for 5 years and experienced it myself.
They will tell you to your face go back to California
Even though you are not from there. If you are a tourist
You may not see this although all employees at hotels
Are nice to you if you grease there hands with a tip
I always told locals there is more Aloha in the states then in Maui
Hey Rob, you are right, the locals who many by the way are also long term transplants from the mainland, don’t like to wait in line at restaurants or wait in line at the intersection or be locked out of beach and surf access by the tourists.
County officials are actually same way… they place extra taxes on non locals, tax the heck out of the tourists and supposedly think that the lower cost housing would magically come if the tourists left while at the same time they are trying to get rid of the transient rental program with idea that the houses that rent for 1500 a day will become available to locals working at McDonalds… Government in Hawaii ( and everywhere) really have no concept how economics work… well they are going to find out- people won’t come but for other reasons and hotels will get MORE expensive not less as many won’t survive with 50% or less occupancy rates… restaurants will fail with fewer visitors and more employees will be lost. Maui has got a 4-6 month reprieve while the super charged unemployment kicks in but after thats over there will be many people leaving the island because of lack of jobs and government will have to increase taxes ( how do they do that when property values are dropping ?) Basically Hawaii is screwed. Next movement will be not how to get rid of tourists but how do we get rid of incompetent and useless government workers who sap all business out off the islands? IGE says 20% pay cuts… not enough… get rid of 20% as well as not needed. Rail program will be a complete funding disaster that no one will use… and now Maui has to pay fines and build new sewage systems as they have been pumping treated waste water deep into the ground near the shore ( you get your water from the water lens in each island) and destroying offshore coral for last 30 years and like next 10-20 since it takes that long for water to percolate…. and should I remind you about the failed ferry boat experience and the ongoing failure in building the worlds largest telescope on Mauna Kea. Hawaii has so many disasters going for it
that actually, tourism is probably the smallest problem when put into proper perspective… GOOD LUCK we will all need it over the next few years- buckle up, its going to be a rough ride.
I think Rob K’s observations are right on the money. Certainly the “vibe” from “locals” is different on different islands–and in different parts of the same island. For example, you could spend a week in Honolulu and never once get a bad vibe from anyone local… because Honolulu is a crowded, modern, ruined place that is typically over-run with tourists–and the few locals that you might encounter there are getting paid to serve you–either in hotels or bars or restaurants or shops. So, that’s what’s EXPECTED there. But if you wander too far out of that area–and bump into some of the more hardcore locals… out toward Ewa Beach and all the way up the coast toward Waianae and Keawaula… your interactions can be dramatically different even on Oahu.
The population density on Maui is WAY lower than Oahu. And the locals there tend to be a lot more aggro towards tourists and non-natives in general. And, to be fair, their “way of life” is really under threat–if not already ruined–by throngs of honeymooners and other visitors. Ironically, it’s Maui’s generally unspoiled natural beauty and low-density that makes it so popular–and is thus causing its own destruction. If you’re a local and you live somewhere along Mana Road… and you have to wait in long lines of tourist traffic to get out and go to work and get your groceries and run your errands every day–that’s going to wear on you after a while. And if you’re a local and you want to take your family to the 7 Sacred Pools for the day and when you get there it is mobbed with white-skinned tourists–that’s going to wear on your after a while, too. It’s the death by a 1000 cuts. None of them are major / serious offenses. But when you can’t even afford to buy the cheapest house on your own island–because wealthy foreigners have driven up prices to astronomical levels–how could you NOT feel resentment about that? Or if the only jobs available to you are tourist related–or constructing expensive houses for rich white people–how could you NOT come to eventually despise those people?
So, the question isn’t whether or not MANY Hawaiians on ALL of the islands have a Love/Hate relationship with tourism. Because they do. And they should. The real question is: Should it matter to you as a visitor? Should you NOT come to Hawaii just because some if not all of the locals don’t want you to come? Should that be the deciding factor? Because I would venture that that Love/Hate relationship between locals and tourists exists EVERYWHERE in the world that tourists throng to.
In a “crisis”, people show their true colors very quickly. And for sure the locals on Maui were the first that I saw on the news protesting against tourism and having small rallies and carrying signs that all said some version of “Tourists, Stay Home!” That thin veil of civility disappears very quickly when you add fear and ignorance together in a situation like this. It has happened over the millennia and will happen until the end of time: Whenever there’s a problem or a crisis, the blame immediately gets shifted to the outsider–the “other”. This has happened over and over again globally and in Hawaii specifically–as waves of cheap foreign labor were brought here to work different booms–mainly in sugar. Every time there was disease or high unemployment or civil unrest, the fingers immediately started pointing toward the foreigners as the source of the problem(s). (Just look at the way America treated its Japanese and German-ancestored citizens during WWII.)
So, again, should you CARE if the locals really don’t want you in Hawaii? Is it going to AFFECT your vacation and your experience here? That’s really the question.
But who even is a LOCAL? Do you validate the feelings of someone living there 5 years/10/20?
We have been spending our vacations every year for over 20 years in Hawaii. This year we had to cancel and everyone knows why. If you respect the culture the locals are amazing. If you disrespect good luck. We all know that Hawaii survives by tourism dollars, One thing we have to remember is Hawaii is not like the mainland, their hospitals are not the same size or equipped to handle such a disaster as what’s happening. If you put yourself in the shoes of locals you can only imagine how hard it is for them worrying not only about loved ones and family but for the first time having to cut off the hand that feeds them by stopping visitors. Everyone in the entire world is under tremendous pressure right now, everyone needs Aloha. This will pass, things will change but we will all overcome this at some point and enjoy Aloha again.
Much Mahalo to BeatofHawaii🤙🏻
Hi Adam.
Thanks again.
Aloha.
We have gone to Kauai every year for the past 20 yrs. We have always been greeted with friendly people everywhere. As a matter if fact we and our children have developed wonderful relationships with local residents and look forward to seeing them.
terrific videos. when I visit, luckily I stay with friends and come for at least 2 weeks. I believe I am aware of the issues and do try to respect the people and the land. it is so important. thanks for your website…it provides a great deal of information. I visit Oahu and stay in kailua and on kauai in priceville area. I am fine with the Hanalei to See Beach restrictions…better for all than the way is used to be. I am on the side of treading lightly wherever I go. thanks you
Hi Mary.
Thanks for all your comments and hanging in there with us for the past 8 years.
Aloha.
These videos well represent the local/tourist dilemma. We live in a Colorado ski resort so like to think we have an understanding of tourism relations. Yes, we get tired of tourists in our town but are well aware of what happens to our local economy without tourists. A prime example is the recent early shut down of our ski season due to this. When we are in Kauai, we try to be vigilantly aware that we are visitors and must respect the local lands and customs. In the 4 years we’ve been going to Kauai, we have alway felt welcomed by the locals but we can see why they get upset as we have observed how disrespectful other tourists can be. It’s not that hard to coexist – be kind, friendly, respectful, patient and generous. Aloha spirit goes a long way!
Mahalo!
Hi Annette.
Thanks for your comments over the past 5 years.
Aloha.
I have visited the majority of the Hawaiian islands for years – at least 25, and have felt welcomed at least 90% of the time. The other 10% was us attempting to fit in and join activities that were more aimed towards the locals. We had to cancel our trip in April this year, but are still hoping to get go to Hawaii before the year end. We go every year for at least two weeks.
Mahalo.
Hi RM.
Thanks.
Aloha.
Thank- you for being brave enough to put this thoughtful question out there. I have been coming to the Islands since 1992. My reason is a love of the people, the culture and the natural beauty. If I were just looking for white sandy beaches and water activities I can find that here on the mainland. The Islands and the people claimed a piece of my heart that first visit and it has always felt like my soul is home. I have on just a few occasions felt the hostility against tourists. It has been very rare. About 97% of the time it is warm genuine aloha. Whether it is someone whose livelihood is tourism or a local Ohana enjoying family day on the beach. Going hey you should go check dis. I have been invited to a Japanese family’s home to spend New Years with them & learn of their hospitality, traditions & culture. Welcomed into local churches as though I was one of their church family etc. I always try to be respectful as well as clean litter at beaches etc. when I am there. I do think some islands there is more of an anger against tourists as they try to preserve the old style ways and we are perceived as a threat to that. I understand that, as I experienced Kauai long before the Kapaa traffic jam etc. With tourism comes growth & progress.
I do hope though as we are coming out of the first phase of this unknown pan demic that this would be a time that Hawaii can press the reset button. Hopefully there will be a way to develop jobs in the green energy fields, agriculture , craft brew businesses and even tiny home builders. These would be jobs developed in areas where the islands jobs are not totally dependent on the tourist dollars. These are jobs that would benefit locals with a dependable food supply, clean energy jobs that respect the land, and housing that not only employs local tradesmen but gives young people a chance at finding affordable housing so they do not have to leave home to make their way. I will return again someday when it is safe to travel. Thankful for the locals that welcome me and hoping that no one ever feels anger or hated while there. There’s enough aloha to go around.
Hi Trudy.
Thanks for all of your comments.
Aloha.
I’m originally from’Oahu, currently living in Tucson,AZ AND trying to move to Hilo. I am of Hawaiian descent.
I’m sorry to hear about anybody having a bad experience about visiting Hawai’i in general. Some of us locals don’t get the fact that ALL the islands NEED tourism and THOSE are the ones who, not only make trouble for the tourists but, the locals as well.
I believe that, if you’re a tourist who’d like to visit Hawai’i, BEFORE you come you should read about our islands, our culture, our history and anything else that the islands offer. That way, not only will you enjoy the islands, you’ll be more respectful towards them and its people and be humble as well. MOST of the tourists who visit are just interested going to the beach and shopping, I feel like that those ones are the ones who DON’T care about our culture or its people and act ignorant by saying how WE are supposed to be “lucky” that they came TO the islands. THOSE kind of tourists make other tourists look bad, just like when we have ignorant locals telling the tourists to go back to where they came from, they make all the OTHER locals look bad as well.
So… when you guys want to go and visit, learn ALL you can learn about us AND our culture then, when you come and we SEE that you show respect for us and the ‘aina…THEN, I do believe that you WILL have a WONDERFUL experience!
Aloha🌺
Hi Emma.
Thanks.
Aloha.
Just out of curiosity, did you bone up on Arizona history before moving there?
My brother and his family live on the Big Island. We would love to come visit and I understand the fear about the vi rus. I told my brother that Hawaii should open up to all Hawaiian residents. Open up the beaches, the ice cream trucks, the food places. Keep visitors quar antined for the time being, but let the locals keep the economy going and let the locals enjoy Hawaii for themselves while they still can. Visitors will return and for most locals this “quar antine” time may be the most beautiful time they will remember. Like old Hawaii before the tourists. I have so much I want to say, and the one thing is that fear won’t keep you from dying, but fear will keep you from living. Aloha.
Hi Kareem.
Thanks. Good to see you. You were one of our first commentors back in 2008.
Aloha.
Aloha, I get most of my info from you guys. A appreciate you. Visited Kauai with my son with Autism back in 2018. It was our first time. My wife and daughter were in New York. Kauai is everything I thought Hawaii would be. I told my wife how great it was and we want to make it part of our next trip. Keep up the great work, BOH. Aloha.
Hi Kareem.
Thank you!
Aloha.
Have not been to Hawaii in probably 5-6 years, but had intended to last year, but failed to get reservations I wanted. Unfortunately I am not one of those WEALTHY individuals that most natives appear to like better because they have more money to spend. I try and stay at affordable places and those seem to be few and far between. Now I think that the “Powers that be” have put some type of restrictions on individuals and others who own and try to rent out their additional properties that are forcing them to try and rent for longer periods of time, so maybe some blame should be placed there. Either way, my money is GREEN like all others and when the natives are not getting enough of it, maybe they will invite me back. Is it still sought out and visited by a lot of Asians? Maybe they would rather have them!!
I am in awe of Hawaiian lands, people and culture. When I visit, I see it as a gift for my soul. In all my trips since 1975, I have not encountered any negative comments, actions or feelings from locals. This Texan is looking forward to the honor for my next opportunity to embrace the beauty of the people and their islands. Aloha.
Hi Terry.
Thanks.
Aloha.
Love Beat of Hawaii. Mahalo for providing it for all of us!
Hi Charla.
You just made our day. Thank you.
Aloha.
Maui is our happy place and has been for 40 years. We live in a resort town on the mainland and have a similar attitude by the locals during the high seasons.After the explosion of this, much blame was put on the tourists. It’s not fare to do so at all. We need the influx of visitors to help the economy and keep the locals working. Hopefully people can see this now and be more hospitable. This is a land we all have to share, respect it and people that manage it. Aloha
Hi Lisa.
Thanks.
Aloha.
We’ve been coming to Hawaii as a couple and then as a family of three for so long. We love Hawaii and we love residents there.
As a visitor, you need to respect the rules and respect the people of Hawaii. But then again, we should always respect each other and be kind to each other. I want to come back to Hawaii more than anyone and to do so, visitors need to follow certain rules, protect environment and behave. I’m glad Hawaii said no to visitors during this time. Why no? They’re just doing so to protect their people and state. Everyone is doing so. Wouldn’t you want to protect your family and home from others if there’s an outbreak? Would you let any random people in? I don’t think so.
Just a bit more time and doors will be opened.
Until then, take care Hawaii and aloha.
Until then,
Hi GG.
Thanks.
Aloha.
I am so saddened by this whole crisis. We have been going to Maui yearly, and have moved our trip to the end of a July, in hopes that the travel ban will be lifted and we can enjoy Hawai’i and all it’s splendor. We love the culture and locals and respect their feelings. I think the majority of tourists are kind and respectful and responsible.
I think there is a huge difference – and this should be distinguished in surveys – between locals and Hawaiians. If you live on Hawaii for 20 years you are probably considered a local, but you will never be Hawaiian. Most (native) Hawaiians probably dislike tourists (or better said tourism). I can see tourists can be seen as an invasion for them, using their land for leisure. For sure most tourists are aware how important the land is for Hawaiians, but as always, 1 bad happening overshadows a 1000 good ones. Great topic!
I get it. A blessing and a curse. I live in So. AZ the economy of which depends on winter tourism. Snowbirds if you will. The population increase taxes our infrastructure to the max. I so love it when the heat sends them home for five months. So we try to be polite guests when we visit you.
There was an outstanding front page story in last Sundays Star Advertiser. It summed up what is a growing sentiment that
as we come out of this pan demic we need to look at ways to protect the Aina and nurture a tourist industry that
is more focused on quality then quantity. We simply cannot support growth at any cost. It isn’t good for the residents and isn’t good for the Hawaii that visitors are coming here to experience.
Expect more of what Kauai did. There should be more user fees and restrictions that protect the environment, not less.
Ideally Hawaii would be a little less dependent on tourism and a leader in green industry innovation and jobs.
I was lucky enough to have a 3 week stay on Oahu this January. Stayed with my sister, who lives on the main military base. I did a lot of solo sight seeing. By far my favorite activity was snorkeling. I fell in love with the ocean and the sea creatures!
I found local residents to be mostly ambivalent, a kind of tourist fatigue, which I think is totally understandable. I did have a negative experience or two, which were upsetting. I also witnessed tourists behaving poorly, oblivious to those around them. Like anywhere with heavy tourism, rules to protect the natural resources are essential and education is key. Thanks for this dialogue.
Hi Holly.
Thank you.
Aloha.
As a frequent visitor to Hawaii, once or twice a year, I find most native Hawaiians to be rather “cool” toward visitors. They’re not rude or unpleasant, just very detached. On the other hand, people who have moved to Hawaii and now call it home, mainly former mainlanders, are often the most friendly,warm and welcoming.
I do not usually comment on these things, for some reason I am. I have been to Hawaii 3 times, coming from NY it is an expense trip. I have family on Kauai, and at one point my brother was stationed At Pearl Harbor. It is one of my favorite destinations, we were hoping to go this summer (unlikely now). I have never felt unwanted in Hawaii, most of my encounters have been very friendly. That being said, I live in a tourist destination, so I understand the feeling of the locals. They like the money tourism brings, but not the crowds and the disrespect for there home. As a result, I feel I may go out of my way to be respectful. I am also usually with my family that lives on the island. Given our current health pan demic, I am honestly suprised that Hawaii is letting in any visitors. If the rate of infection in Kauai, rose like it did in NY, the island simply would not have the hospital capacity needed. Personnally, I think it is irresponsible for people to be traveling to Hawaii now. As beautiful as it is, the beauty will still be there in 6 months. I guess I will end on, if you show respect, respect tends to be given in return.
Our family has been raised with the words, “Leave the world a little better than when you came.” We have seen great partnerships between mainland people and locals through interest and support of their local heritage. And, you’re right, just showing respect and interest goes a long way…