117 thoughts on “Your Future Maui Vacation May Save the Island from Further Disaster”
Linda
We don’t know what is the best thing to do. We are scheduled to go to Kauai 9/23, then Maui 10/14. We love Hawaii and have been many times, saving after each trip to go again. We want to be respectful, have made a donation and would like to help. We pray for the dead and all those suffering. Should we stay away out of respect or go and help support the island?
You didn’t mention whether you’re traveling to West Maui. If not, then it is a personal decision, with recent guidance from the state suggesting that travel to Maui resume for obvious reasons.
Thanks. That location, being in West Maui, would be a wait and see situation. In the next couple of weeks we anticipate more clarity and direction from the state. They just aren’t there yet.
We are in a similar situation. We are planning on visiting Kauai in late October and we had planned on spending time on Maui into the beginning of November. There are people who feel incredibly “passionate” on both sides of this argument and it’s hard to navigate.
Hoping to have some clarity from Hawaii state officials in the coming weeks.
It’s possible that those who are “incredibly passionate” for visitors not to come may have also voiced that opinion when things were normal, so keep that in mind. The few residents that don’t rely in any way on tourism (a pretty short list) are naturally going to be anti-tourist.
Is there adequate infrastructure for the rest of the island to continue tourism? Yes income for the state is important but are all services ready for an unexpected problem elsewhere?!
The islands need to start finding economic alternatives to tourism. For many decades, pineapple and sugarcane were Hawaii’s primary industries, and tourism was a drop in the bucket. We also grew our own food and raised our own livestock. We need a return to self-sufficiency; we need meaningful economic activities that keep us independent of tourism, an industry that has honestly eroded the quality of life for those born and raised in the islands.
I am in South Maui and am a member of a Mommy Maui Facebook page. I can confirm that there is a diaper shortage due to people purchasing them too aggressively for the West Side. Moms elsewhere on the island are asking other moms for any extras. Costco was out on Friday and got restocked Sunday morning by other island Costcos, but by Sunday evening I can confirm that they were sold out again. Local groups have called on people to stop buying anything until specific needs are requested. Last I heard, radios, propane, flashlights and gas were the big needs. As power is restored and Lahaina residents are eventually allowed to return, I’m guessing items like gloves, masks, etc will be a major need. However, due to asbestos in Front Street buildings, clean up might be limited to professionals. For now, cash is the best way to support Maui.
My thought is that neither extreme is correct. People that don’t need to be in West Maui need to leave and not come back until some areas are suitable again which may take months or years. Federal and State Aid needs to come as soon as possible to rebuild West Maui.
Visitors need to come back to the rest of Maui to keep the island ecomomy going and start the process of building West Maui back to the way it was. Town by Town, Street by Street, Shop by Shop, House by House. It is not an all or nothing situation. It is a slow long process to rebuild.
Here is a copy of a text message that my friend Cindy sent me a few minutes ago. She arrived today and is spending eight nights in my condo in Kihei. This BOH post is exactly what we’ve been saying to each other all week. When on the island we only rent from local car companies. Please consider what this young man is saying. The survivors need your help.
I am so happy I am here. They need to change the “dont come” status. K… said if the maui car rental business does not pick up, they are going to lay people off, he is worried about losing his job, I feel bad for him. He said “they need to stop with all the negative on social media”.
In any case thanks again. We are about to go to the beach. Have a good night.
My girlfriend and I are scheduled south Maui first week in September. We have considered option to cancel, but decided to continue with our plans. The five days we only plan to stay in Wailea resort hotels and use the restaurants within walking distance. Our original plan even before the fire was not to rent a car.
I’ve talked with hospitality workers in that area and they are pleading for us not to cancel. Many of these workers rely on tips with customers in their establishments to make a living and survive. We have utmost respect for the pain, but also want to part of the healing that needs to happen. We live in Napa Valley and have had two major fires here ourselves. Its difficult to navigate, but we encouraged return visitors when it was safe for us.
I hope this helps anyone in the same situation making this very difficult decision for themselves.
I just want to help. I wish I could get there and volunteer at shelters. Always Hawaiian at heart Mau loa. Godspeed Lahaina and it’s Ohana. I have donated from Vegas, the 9th Island. Malama Pono!
I moved from the islands to Northern California. In the last five years, I’ve seen the Camp Fire, the Sheep Fire, the Claremont Fire, and the Dixie Fire go through my communities. In the immediate aftermath of all of them, there was more help than anyone knew what do to with. Five years later, there are still not enough homes, not enough jobs, and not enough people to process rebuilding, not just in terms of materials, but also planning permits, environmental surveys and cleanup, reforestation efforts. Disasters are socioeconomic; those with money and insurance move elsewhere or rebuild, those with some money possibly move elsewhere or find somewhere to make do, the poor are still homeless five years later, every bit as when they fled to camp in a Walmart parking lot.
I’m not here to tell anyone what they should or shouldn’t do, or what Maui needs most five years from now, but ask yourselves: if you had tickets for Times Square on September 12, 2001, or New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, or Japan after Fukushima, would you still feel the same about your trip cancelation? Yes, part of that is on government accountability, transparency, and provision for its citizens. But we should also make sure our kuleana is genuine, and not just a need to save face. We are malihini. Visitors. Our place is not to decide. It is to listen and send aloha where it’s needed when it’s asked for.
My husband and I were scheduled to stay in Napili Bay on September 15th for 10 days celebrating our 40th anniversary and birthdays. It is with great sadness we read the official notice on our resort’s website, as they share how they have staff that are unaccounted for, as well as over 30 staff that have lost their homes (which they are providing rooms for) all of which is heartbreaking and tragic. We can’t even think about being in the way of housing and recovery efforts for the residents of Maui. Our travel person is offering another island but honestly, we feel we will be imposing and taking resources that should be dedicated to the West Maui losses and those in need. There is not consistent information available to make informed decisions. We are all for supporting tourism but celebrating during such a time of tragedy and disaster does not feel right.
I’ll take the State of Florida’s response to Hurricane Ian 7 days a week and twice in Sundays…
This is becoming an unmitigated response disaster.
I knew from hour 1, yelling at tourists to leave was a terrible idea. Hawaii’s go to tactic is the “blame others” game.
Nobody in FL yelled at tourists, their Gov got on camera and said ” we will arrest looters”, they rebuilt a bridge in 10 days and wthin 250 days Sanibel Island was open for business. The State didn’t regulate who could help, or block ” locals” from helping rebuild roofs, clean yards/roads…
This irresponsible ” get off our island” rhetoric will be the undoing of Maui.
First, my thoughts and prayers have been with the people of Maui since I Began to hear of the fire. I can’t even imagine the devastation the residents of west Maui must be experiencing. As I watch what’s happened to Lahaina I’m totally horrified. I cant possibly say that I know how they feel but, I can tell them that my heart aches for all who have lost lives, businesses.
My family and I visit the islands quite regularly. I spent 2 weeks in maui just last April. I’m so happy I got to see it recently. No matter how things are rebuilt, it will never be the same.
I intend to visit Maui again next year. In the mean time I’ve been in contact with people we have gotten to know through the years. We have been sending weekly donations to them to use to help those that have suffered such catastrophic losses. I would highly recommend others do the same. Send what you can, as often as you can.
Something that’s a concern to me is some of what I’m hearing come out of maui from the locals. Things like visitors are still coming & consuming resources needed by Maui fire victims. I would certainly hope that isn’t the case. But, what I would warn the locals of is not to start a war between visitors and locals like the one that went on during Covid. It’s very unnecessary and hurtful. Please don’t exaggerate what tourists might be doing. Remember, we all need each other. Let’s all help each other.
Mahalo,
TJ
My wife and I have reservations for a two week period during September in the Wailea area. The last thing we want to do is get in the way of the recovery for Maui from the fires. I have read the official statements and had conversations with the manager of the condo we have rented and paid for. Listening to the official statements and looking at the airline congestion my feelings tell me to cancel. I use the word cancel because the condo will not refund or postpone my reservations and I will loose the total cost of the condo unless there is an official statement to stay away. We all would be better off if Maui officials would make a specific ruling for specific areas that we can take into consideration. Lost at this point.
This is a great post. I have a reservation coming up in October on the west side of Maui, and we’ve been told that if the resort is open, we will not get any refund. No offer to split the cost, nothing. I don’t think it’s fair that the vacationer has to give up $10k+, and the condo owner pockets the money, if we are trying to do the right thing. So I guess the right thing is going and being a good visitor if the resort is open, and obviously staying home if the resort is closed.
We had a Kaanapali trip scheduled for early December and elected to cancel. We’ve donated most of that fund to Maui Strong, as we feel it’s just too soon, at least in our minds to embark on a vacation so near a tragedy that affects so many. We’ve decided to wait until early 2024 to rebook a West Maui stay, with hopes of engaging with local volunteer efforts to assist how we can. Canceling was a difficult decision because we know tourism is the driving economic force, but our hearts tell us Maui needs some time to heal. I hope we’re not wrong. We’ve been Hawaii visitors for nearly 30 years, albeit between Maui, Kauai and the Big Island, and will continue to support how best we can with hopes we’re making the right decision for the residents of Hawaii. Our hearts are with our brothers and sisters in Hawaii whether they know it or not.
FEMA has blocked 100 rooms at the Hilton Hawaiian Village (HHV) in Waikiki for some of their team members because there are not enough rooms on Maui (source: HHV Front Desk Management 8/13/23).
Everyday, that FEMA team has to transport to/from HNL. Go through TSA twice/day. Then transport to/from OGG. Their time would be significantly more productive if they were actually staying on Maui.
It is definitely a balancing act between emergency and economic need. However for these first terrifying days/weeks, I absolutely think it was a prudent call to evacuate Maui. They need the resources for displaced residents and emergency responders. When there is less of a need for emergency services, then a shift can be made towards economic recovery.
Valid points from Eric and Julie.
I visited Maui for the first time 38 years ago on my honeymoon and have gone back every year, sometimes multiple times. So, I consider this my “second home”…it’s my happy place! It pains me deeply to see the pain this event has placed upon these beautiful people.
But I’m leaning more towards Erics comments…the island needs tourism to resume ASAP. West Maui is definitely not a place to be right now, but the other accessible parts need to stay vibrant. The entire island will almost cease to exist if everybody stays away now. It will be just like when Covid hit, and the islands shut down…I call it the Hawaii depression!
For me, it’s a tough call. I’m scheduled to be in Maui on Sept.4. Julie stated that “airlines are honoring your plane tickets”…that’s partially correct…AA is only allowing changes or cancellations for Aug.9-18 arrivals, so right now my Sept. 4 flight if cancelled is a total loss. Oh, and guess what…my West Maui rental will probably not be accessible for my trip.
So just waiting to see how best I can support the people of Maui!
We had actually planned a move to the West Coast a few months ago and today while dropping off our truck for transport and getting a rental car at the airport we were reminded of how it was during covid. The entrance field coming into the airport was full of rental cars. When we parked and walked up to the Hertz counter we were the only ones there. The service agent said she hoped to not end up in the unemployment line again. 🥹
We were scheduled to come to Maui on the 2nd of September but we do not feel like it is appropriate for us to come to a vacation given all the life and life long work that has been lost. We will be asking for a refund on tickets and activities we scheduled. Our heats and prayers are lifted up for those impacted by this disaster in their life.
Mahalo for sharing the complexity of this situation for us travelers. Today I decided to cancel my plans to visit Maui in October. Partially, due to the fact that the hotel I was booked in Kaanapali suggested to postpone future trips. If I had booked another part of Maui I would have considered keeping my plans. But I feel West Maui needs to heal before I can come back as a tourist. I look forward to the time when the wounds aren’t so fresh.
I have reservations for the beginning of March at a small condo complex in the Honokowai area. I know it’s just outside the area directly affected and am having conflicted thoughts about whether or not to keep my reservation. I completely get both sides of the argument. I want to help – I’ve donated what I can – but I’m still not sure what’s right. There are too many pros and cons at this point. I love Maui. I visit every year. Just not sure what to do
We have reservations for two weeks in November at a West Maui resort condo, where we frequently enjoy a relaxed stay. Our visits, like those of most others, have taken advantage of the now non-existent whale watching and snorkel boat trips, dining out options, entertainment, recreational activities and shopping for supplies, groceries and gifts at local Lahina establishments.
We love Maui and cherish the memories of the wonderfully helpful and friendly people we have encountered during our many years of infrequent visits to the island.
With a heavy heart, concern and respect for the residents, business owners, employees and support services, who all depend on tourism trade, we just cancelled our airline reservation. And we’ll need to do the same with the condo owner. Our concern – we don’t want to be a burden on what will surely still be limited resources for that part of Maui. But equally concerning, is the lack of revenue that cancellations like this from us and others will do to the overall island economy.
So, I proposed the following to my wife… “What do you think about us donating a good portion of what we’d normally spend for a typical Maui visit to help support the local residents?”
If we can identify the appropriate organization(s) where we know our dollars can be put to use and help rebuild the community, then that is most likely what will will do.
Erick, this is the list that Civil Beat (a local news organization) compiled for cash donations:
*Hawaii Community Foundation Maui Strong fund: Focusing on rapid response and working with local nonprofits to understand community needs.
*Maui Food Bank: Collecting and distributing food to help the hungry in Maui County.
*Maui United Way: Providing direct relief to families and nonprofits.
*The Salvation Army Hawaiian and Pacific Islands Division: Providing food and resources for evacuees.
*Public Schools of Hawaii Foundation: Partnering with the state Department of Education to support school communities in West Maui through Oct. 1.
*Council for Native Hawaiian Advancement: Matching up to $1.5 million in donations for Maui fire victims as of Friday evening.
*Maui Humane Society: Supporting shelters for displaced people and animals, and caring for injured animals.
*World Central Kitchen: Providing meals to people in need by partnering with local organizations.
*Hawaii Lions Foundation: Matching up to $25,000 in donations for Maui disaster relief efforts.
People who make statements on social media of not wanting tourist on Maui do not understand the economics of their statement.
Many had no skin in the game before the fire, no job, no debt, no mortgage, no car payment or payroll to meet. They don’t own businesses, pay taxes, annual permits or license fees.
They’d be the first ones to complain when Costco, Walmart, Target, Safeway etc. all closed for lack of business.
Individuals who survived the fire that worked in the customer service industry are going to need employment.
Owners of customer service businesses located in areas not affected by fire who’ve had staffing issues since covid will welcome these individuals with open arms.
It’s a fluid situation and you’re going to get some mixed signals, but don’t kill the golden goose that will rebuild and save Maui.
Don’t think I could enjoy vacation with all those lives lost down the street. Just saying it’s pretty morbid. Was there any decision a government official made that was correct at any point?
So sorry for the Lahiana families whose homes and businesses were destroy or lost loved ones. They need time to grieve and renew their spirits. That said, the other local family and friends should be allowed to go help there Lahiana family or friends. I heard other family members who lived on the other side of the island were not allowed to come in to help their relatives. Better communication needs to be established to help the grieving families. Tourist should NOT be given more privileges over the Lahiana families. Maybe a specific time should be allotted to Lahiana family and friends to move freely in the area.
Although Tourism is the economic lifeline of Maui, they should be advised to act with understanding and compassion towards those affected by this great tragedy. The Lahiana people are hurting. Please be respectful and helpful.
Thank you for all your efforts on keeping us updated! I truly appreciate it.
I’m just as many other time share owners in Maui trying to make the best decision for the island and the residents there.
I do have reservations booked in west Maui towards end of October and I feel split on what’s the right decision at this time. I want to help besides donating money… maybe we can offer our assistance in other ways as well! Any and all thoughts would be appreciated.
It would be great if tourists are welcomed back, if the airlines would waive the bag fee for any packed bag/box filled with clothes, toiletries and other non perishable items that could be donated to displaced Maui residents.
Reality is that tourism is the economic engine that supports Maui (and the whole state). So yes, tourists need to return to the 85% of Maui that’s undamaged. Tourists can have a typical Hawai’i vacation and support the people and businesses who desperately need help. It’s a win-win.
This is a tough one. We live on the big island and had planned to travel to Maui for a couple of days for a change of scenery but given what happened we are postponing. I have a lot of friends on the island and they are still devastated and in shock. I do think that tourism needs to come back and as quick as it can however right now a message from the governor on Facebook saying to come back isn’t enough. We’ve already seen that the governor doesn’t have the information. We need to hear from the mayor who is boots on the ground. The island needs basic infrastructure back in place – cell service, water, and electricity. The island doesn’t need a bunch of Looky-loos coming to see the fire damage of Lahaina which will only impede the progress made to restore vital functions and deliver much needed supplies. unfortunately we cannot expect the tourists to take this into consideration.
With about 60,000+, or more, visitors/tourists on Maui on a given day, let them in where they can fit. The residents who need a place to stay, wonderful idea to house them at vacation properties. Using units for visitors not needed by those who need a place to stay it will be the visitors who will pay the bulk of the cost. We need to remember that the “government” is us, us taxpayers. So when the “government” pays, we pay.
I am all in favor of helping all those who had loses but there is a huge resource in tourist dollars to help fund what is needed. Tap into it!
We love Maui, the people and have been there on vacation 25-30 times. You don’t have to convince us to go! One of my vendors is having a large gathering in Wailea in December which I am silently begging them to not cancel. Anyone who feels the same should donate if you can and as much as you can.
We have reservations in West Maui for one month from today. We have not yet cancelled as it is not in the window where airlines or timeshare condos are automatically cancelling and in fact, the timeshare company will penalize us if we cancel. The Maui people are our Ohana and we are heartbroken with them. We spend 4 – 6 weeks in West Maui each year and we want to be there spending our money to help the Maui tourism if they want us. We know our favorite restaurants in Lahaina are gone but we are willing to travel to the other side of the island to help keep them open and the employees employed. If they want us there, we will come. #Mauistrong
500+ people incinerated. No warning despite a multi-million dollar warning system and the exact same weather conditions that sparked the hurricane Lane fire, from which the state and county officials learned nothing. Emotions will be fraught for a long time. Tourists will be an easy target of the anger, even though this has nothing to do with tourists. Like kicking the dog. “Please come but walk on egg shells and be highly respectful (or else)” is not a vacation. The whole situation is awful.
I picked my flight date to coincide with my mother’s (Rosemary) birthday. God rest her soul. She passed on mother’s day over 20 yrs ago. Maui (LaHaina ) was my home town for 5 yrs and it would have been a wonderful birthday present for her,to see me happy. I watched the fire on descent into Maui on my flight. Heart broken doesn’t convey the feeling.
Fire hydrants no water,hot power lines in high winds,no warning sirens ( even though they test them every 1st of each month). There certainly is alot of explaining to do (Mr.Green) rather than jumping on the climate bandwagon. Like it’s never been hot and windy on Maui before.Hmmmmmmmm
I’ve lived in Maui from 1969-1972 (Summers)Been bringing the family there since 1985. With many lifelong Maui residents as friends, I understand the needed protections for the island. As usual in every community, 80% are hard-working, caring law biding families. It’s this 20% that brings the visitor hate and claims Aloha stuff, but it’s just talk. Every city has these crazies.
Let’s not judge Maui, by this 20% and let them create fear in tourism.
It’s a give & take for all of us to help get things back to where they were. I’m coming back for Thanksgiving w/family to spend as much money as possible, helping the Maui economy.
Been to Lahaina many time I live in Australia I cried with you all I still can’t believe Lahaina has gone I pray the people of Lahaina can get through this I cried so I know how you feel sending lots of prayers
We have booked a vacation to Maui in the coming November. We feel and empathize with the people of Maui. However, we are torn between to cancel or still going to Maui. The travel information and comments out there are conflicting. We want to support Maui by bringing business, but on the other hand we don’t want to be a burden. A vacation seems so irrelevant in relation to all the lost lives and the challenges the people of Maui are having to deal with. I am struggling for an answer.
I saw a video today from Maui 24/7 stating central and south Maui are fine and need your stay. However to come and volunteer and help out where needed.
I am in the same situation, reservations for late November. We’ve been coming to Maui for 40 years and love the island and it’s people. So do we come to Kaanapali and support the island or cancel and come back at a future date? We’ll wait and see what happens over the upcoming weeks/months before deciding. Ultimately it might be up to the resort/airlines if they’ll allow us to cancel for a date that far out. Our prayers are with Maui.
Well said. I would be torn too. It’s probably best that the local government makes a decision and sticks with it. I agree that we need to be respectful and give the needed space and support in the short term, but after that, I think supporting Maui’s economy in a tasteful manner by traveling to the island is the best way forward. The timing has to be right.
As a very recent visitor of Maui, one of my first thoughts was to return in the future and support tourism for the island. However, I also questioned, “How soon is too soon?”. Considering the information we have so far, I think you should be okay to travel in November. Just like some of the locals have mentioned, you can definitely support other parts of the island. As long as you’re mindful of local residents and stick to other areas away from West Maui, you are supporting the island as a whole. I’m more worried about the hotels profiting off the locals.
Aloha…..I say, stay away from Maui out of respect for the people of Maui. Be reminded that a lot have lost a lot including family members, property etc. Ask yourself, what Would you do if you were in their place?
So, are there any levels of government from Maui County on up that aren’t currently decision-making via knee-jerk?
My first thought when they announced that they were asking all tourists to leave the island was that they were about to trash the local economy, but I also figured they probably knew more about the local infrastructure and what it could support than I do.
There’s a lot of misinformation out there. Government officials were asking visitors to leave because power was out at West Maui hotels. There were fires in Kula that came close to some inns. And a fire in Kihei, although that wasn’t close to any of the resorts. There’s a concern that the hotels, timeshare units, B&B, etc. are needed for displaced local residents. But all residents need to keep working and the visitor industry employs many of them. Hotels in south Maui are open and not sold out.
BOH reported visitors who left Maui are crowding Waikiki, but I know of only two major hotels that were sold out this weekend. Not sure where that report came from.
Where did it come from? We were there. It was nuts in Honolulu and largely over the top as a result of those coming from Maui. There were no rental cars either.
On another site, I’ve received three private posts that were extremely nasty – even obscene and threatening – because I espoused the idea of continuing to support Maui tourism. I realize that visiting other islands contributes just as well to the State Relief Coffers as does visiting Maui but as Seth said in your post, taking away people’s jobs on Maui just does further damage to their lives and futures. Having said that, I’ve also been told by a friend that her cousins, who had lost family as has she, were threatened with their jobs if they didn’t show up to do hula at a local resort’s luau and when they at times cried, they were further threatened. So the conundrum continues.
That is just really sad for you to have experienced that. I have a feeling those folks have misplaced anger on behalf of the people of Maui and aren’t Maui residents themselves. In the case of the employer threatening the employees, the problem is the employer. They’re the selfish ones with no empathy. They should be exposed for their selfishness.
We don’t know what is the best thing to do. We are scheduled to go to Kauai 9/23, then Maui 10/14. We love Hawaii and have been many times, saving after each trip to go again. We want to be respectful, have made a donation and would like to help. We pray for the dead and all those suffering. Should we stay away out of respect or go and help support the island?
Hi Linda.
You didn’t mention whether you’re traveling to West Maui. If not, then it is a personal decision, with recent guidance from the state suggesting that travel to Maui resume for obvious reasons.
Aloha.
We are booked into Kahana Beach for three weeks 10/14-11/4.
Hi Linda.
Thanks. That location, being in West Maui, would be a wait and see situation. In the next couple of weeks we anticipate more clarity and direction from the state. They just aren’t there yet.
Aloha.
We are in a similar situation. We are planning on visiting Kauai in late October and we had planned on spending time on Maui into the beginning of November. There are people who feel incredibly “passionate” on both sides of this argument and it’s hard to navigate.
Hoping to have some clarity from Hawaii state officials in the coming weeks.
It’s possible that those who are “incredibly passionate” for visitors not to come may have also voiced that opinion when things were normal, so keep that in mind. The few residents that don’t rely in any way on tourism (a pretty short list) are naturally going to be anti-tourist.
Is there adequate infrastructure for the rest of the island to continue tourism? Yes income for the state is important but are all services ready for an unexpected problem elsewhere?!
hi Harriett.
That is the question, to which there is not a clear answer. Also, those circumstances will change as time passes.
Aloha.
The islands need to start finding economic alternatives to tourism. For many decades, pineapple and sugarcane were Hawaii’s primary industries, and tourism was a drop in the bucket. We also grew our own food and raised our own livestock. We need a return to self-sufficiency; we need meaningful economic activities that keep us independent of tourism, an industry that has honestly eroded the quality of life for those born and raised in the islands.
I am in South Maui and am a member of a Mommy Maui Facebook page. I can confirm that there is a diaper shortage due to people purchasing them too aggressively for the West Side. Moms elsewhere on the island are asking other moms for any extras. Costco was out on Friday and got restocked Sunday morning by other island Costcos, but by Sunday evening I can confirm that they were sold out again. Local groups have called on people to stop buying anything until specific needs are requested. Last I heard, radios, propane, flashlights and gas were the big needs. As power is restored and Lahaina residents are eventually allowed to return, I’m guessing items like gloves, masks, etc will be a major need. However, due to asbestos in Front Street buildings, clean up might be limited to professionals. For now, cash is the best way to support Maui.
My thought is that neither extreme is correct. People that don’t need to be in West Maui need to leave and not come back until some areas are suitable again which may take months or years. Federal and State Aid needs to come as soon as possible to rebuild West Maui.
Visitors need to come back to the rest of Maui to keep the island ecomomy going and start the process of building West Maui back to the way it was. Town by Town, Street by Street, Shop by Shop, House by House. It is not an all or nothing situation. It is a slow long process to rebuild.
Here is a copy of a text message that my friend Cindy sent me a few minutes ago. She arrived today and is spending eight nights in my condo in Kihei. This BOH post is exactly what we’ve been saying to each other all week. When on the island we only rent from local car companies. Please consider what this young man is saying. The survivors need your help.
I am so happy I am here. They need to change the “dont come” status. K… said if the maui car rental business does not pick up, they are going to lay people off, he is worried about losing his job, I feel bad for him. He said “they need to stop with all the negative on social media”.
In any case thanks again. We are about to go to the beach. Have a good night.
Hi Richard.
Thanks for sharing that.
Aloha.
My girlfriend and I are scheduled south Maui first week in September. We have considered option to cancel, but decided to continue with our plans. The five days we only plan to stay in Wailea resort hotels and use the restaurants within walking distance. Our original plan even before the fire was not to rent a car.
I’ve talked with hospitality workers in that area and they are pleading for us not to cancel. Many of these workers rely on tips with customers in their establishments to make a living and survive. We have utmost respect for the pain, but also want to part of the healing that needs to happen. We live in Napa Valley and have had two major fires here ourselves. Its difficult to navigate, but we encouraged return visitors when it was safe for us.
I hope this helps anyone in the same situation making this very difficult decision for themselves.
I just want to help. I wish I could get there and volunteer at shelters. Always Hawaiian at heart Mau loa. Godspeed Lahaina and it’s Ohana. I have donated from Vegas, the 9th Island. Malama Pono!
I moved from the islands to Northern California. In the last five years, I’ve seen the Camp Fire, the Sheep Fire, the Claremont Fire, and the Dixie Fire go through my communities. In the immediate aftermath of all of them, there was more help than anyone knew what do to with. Five years later, there are still not enough homes, not enough jobs, and not enough people to process rebuilding, not just in terms of materials, but also planning permits, environmental surveys and cleanup, reforestation efforts. Disasters are socioeconomic; those with money and insurance move elsewhere or rebuild, those with some money possibly move elsewhere or find somewhere to make do, the poor are still homeless five years later, every bit as when they fled to camp in a Walmart parking lot.
I’m not here to tell anyone what they should or shouldn’t do, or what Maui needs most five years from now, but ask yourselves: if you had tickets for Times Square on September 12, 2001, or New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, or Japan after Fukushima, would you still feel the same about your trip cancelation? Yes, part of that is on government accountability, transparency, and provision for its citizens. But we should also make sure our kuleana is genuine, and not just a need to save face. We are malihini. Visitors. Our place is not to decide. It is to listen and send aloha where it’s needed when it’s asked for.
My husband and I were scheduled to stay in Napili Bay on September 15th for 10 days celebrating our 40th anniversary and birthdays. It is with great sadness we read the official notice on our resort’s website, as they share how they have staff that are unaccounted for, as well as over 30 staff that have lost their homes (which they are providing rooms for) all of which is heartbreaking and tragic. We can’t even think about being in the way of housing and recovery efforts for the residents of Maui. Our travel person is offering another island but honestly, we feel we will be imposing and taking resources that should be dedicated to the West Maui losses and those in need. There is not consistent information available to make informed decisions. We are all for supporting tourism but celebrating during such a time of tragedy and disaster does not feel right.
I have been to Maui 3 times, not going back.
I would rather go to Kauai or the Big Island
I’ll take the State of Florida’s response to Hurricane Ian 7 days a week and twice in Sundays…
This is becoming an unmitigated response disaster.
I knew from hour 1, yelling at tourists to leave was a terrible idea. Hawaii’s go to tactic is the “blame others” game.
Nobody in FL yelled at tourists, their Gov got on camera and said ” we will arrest looters”, they rebuilt a bridge in 10 days and wthin 250 days Sanibel Island was open for business. The State didn’t regulate who could help, or block ” locals” from helping rebuild roofs, clean yards/roads…
This irresponsible ” get off our island” rhetoric will be the undoing of Maui.
I agree with your comments whole heartily.
There seems to be a small yet vocal minority in this country that is leading us down a slippery slope.
First, my thoughts and prayers have been with the people of Maui since I Began to hear of the fire. I can’t even imagine the devastation the residents of west Maui must be experiencing. As I watch what’s happened to Lahaina I’m totally horrified. I cant possibly say that I know how they feel but, I can tell them that my heart aches for all who have lost lives, businesses.
My family and I visit the islands quite regularly. I spent 2 weeks in maui just last April. I’m so happy I got to see it recently. No matter how things are rebuilt, it will never be the same.
I intend to visit Maui again next year. In the mean time I’ve been in contact with people we have gotten to know through the years. We have been sending weekly donations to them to use to help those that have suffered such catastrophic losses. I would highly recommend others do the same. Send what you can, as often as you can.
Something that’s a concern to me is some of what I’m hearing come out of maui from the locals. Things like visitors are still coming & consuming resources needed by Maui fire victims. I would certainly hope that isn’t the case. But, what I would warn the locals of is not to start a war between visitors and locals like the one that went on during Covid. It’s very unnecessary and hurtful. Please don’t exaggerate what tourists might be doing. Remember, we all need each other. Let’s all help each other.
Mahalo,
TJ
My wife and I have reservations for a two week period during September in the Wailea area. The last thing we want to do is get in the way of the recovery for Maui from the fires. I have read the official statements and had conversations with the manager of the condo we have rented and paid for. Listening to the official statements and looking at the airline congestion my feelings tell me to cancel. I use the word cancel because the condo will not refund or postpone my reservations and I will loose the total cost of the condo unless there is an official statement to stay away. We all would be better off if Maui officials would make a specific ruling for specific areas that we can take into consideration. Lost at this point.
This is a great post. I have a reservation coming up in October on the west side of Maui, and we’ve been told that if the resort is open, we will not get any refund. No offer to split the cost, nothing. I don’t think it’s fair that the vacationer has to give up $10k+, and the condo owner pockets the money, if we are trying to do the right thing. So I guess the right thing is going and being a good visitor if the resort is open, and obviously staying home if the resort is closed.
We had a Kaanapali trip scheduled for early December and elected to cancel. We’ve donated most of that fund to Maui Strong, as we feel it’s just too soon, at least in our minds to embark on a vacation so near a tragedy that affects so many. We’ve decided to wait until early 2024 to rebook a West Maui stay, with hopes of engaging with local volunteer efforts to assist how we can. Canceling was a difficult decision because we know tourism is the driving economic force, but our hearts tell us Maui needs some time to heal. I hope we’re not wrong. We’ve been Hawaii visitors for nearly 30 years, albeit between Maui, Kauai and the Big Island, and will continue to support how best we can with hopes we’re making the right decision for the residents of Hawaii. Our hearts are with our brothers and sisters in Hawaii whether they know it or not.
FEMA has blocked 100 rooms at the Hilton Hawaiian Village (HHV) in Waikiki for some of their team members because there are not enough rooms on Maui (source: HHV Front Desk Management 8/13/23).
Everyday, that FEMA team has to transport to/from HNL. Go through TSA twice/day. Then transport to/from OGG. Their time would be significantly more productive if they were actually staying on Maui.
It is definitely a balancing act between emergency and economic need. However for these first terrifying days/weeks, I absolutely think it was a prudent call to evacuate Maui. They need the resources for displaced residents and emergency responders. When there is less of a need for emergency services, then a shift can be made towards economic recovery.
God speed Maui.
Valid points from Eric and Julie.
I visited Maui for the first time 38 years ago on my honeymoon and have gone back every year, sometimes multiple times. So, I consider this my “second home”…it’s my happy place! It pains me deeply to see the pain this event has placed upon these beautiful people.
But I’m leaning more towards Erics comments…the island needs tourism to resume ASAP. West Maui is definitely not a place to be right now, but the other accessible parts need to stay vibrant. The entire island will almost cease to exist if everybody stays away now. It will be just like when Covid hit, and the islands shut down…I call it the Hawaii depression!
For me, it’s a tough call. I’m scheduled to be in Maui on Sept.4. Julie stated that “airlines are honoring your plane tickets”…that’s partially correct…AA is only allowing changes or cancellations for Aug.9-18 arrivals, so right now my Sept. 4 flight if cancelled is a total loss. Oh, and guess what…my West Maui rental will probably not be accessible for my trip.
So just waiting to see how best I can support the people of Maui!
We had actually planned a move to the West Coast a few months ago and today while dropping off our truck for transport and getting a rental car at the airport we were reminded of how it was during covid. The entrance field coming into the airport was full of rental cars. When we parked and walked up to the Hertz counter we were the only ones there. The service agent said she hoped to not end up in the unemployment line again. 🥹
We were scheduled to come to Maui on the 2nd of September but we do not feel like it is appropriate for us to come to a vacation given all the life and life long work that has been lost. We will be asking for a refund on tickets and activities we scheduled. Our heats and prayers are lifted up for those impacted by this disaster in their life.
Mahalo for sharing the complexity of this situation for us travelers. Today I decided to cancel my plans to visit Maui in October. Partially, due to the fact that the hotel I was booked in Kaanapali suggested to postpone future trips. If I had booked another part of Maui I would have considered keeping my plans. But I feel West Maui needs to heal before I can come back as a tourist. I look forward to the time when the wounds aren’t so fresh.
I have reservations for the beginning of March at a small condo complex in the Honokowai area. I know it’s just outside the area directly affected and am having conflicted thoughts about whether or not to keep my reservation. I completely get both sides of the argument. I want to help – I’ve donated what I can – but I’m still not sure what’s right. There are too many pros and cons at this point. I love Maui. I visit every year. Just not sure what to do
We have reservations for two weeks in November at a West Maui resort condo, where we frequently enjoy a relaxed stay. Our visits, like those of most others, have taken advantage of the now non-existent whale watching and snorkel boat trips, dining out options, entertainment, recreational activities and shopping for supplies, groceries and gifts at local Lahina establishments.
We love Maui and cherish the memories of the wonderfully helpful and friendly people we have encountered during our many years of infrequent visits to the island.
With a heavy heart, concern and respect for the residents, business owners, employees and support services, who all depend on tourism trade, we just cancelled our airline reservation. And we’ll need to do the same with the condo owner. Our concern – we don’t want to be a burden on what will surely still be limited resources for that part of Maui. But equally concerning, is the lack of revenue that cancellations like this from us and others will do to the overall island economy.
So, I proposed the following to my wife… “What do you think about us donating a good portion of what we’d normally spend for a typical Maui visit to help support the local residents?”
If we can identify the appropriate organization(s) where we know our dollars can be put to use and help rebuild the community, then that is most likely what will will do.
Erick, this is the list that Civil Beat (a local news organization) compiled for cash donations:
*Hawaii Community Foundation Maui Strong fund: Focusing on rapid response and working with local nonprofits to understand community needs.
*Maui Food Bank: Collecting and distributing food to help the hungry in Maui County.
*Maui United Way: Providing direct relief to families and nonprofits.
*The Salvation Army Hawaiian and Pacific Islands Division: Providing food and resources for evacuees.
*Public Schools of Hawaii Foundation: Partnering with the state Department of Education to support school communities in West Maui through Oct. 1.
*Council for Native Hawaiian Advancement: Matching up to $1.5 million in donations for Maui fire victims as of Friday evening.
*Maui Humane Society: Supporting shelters for displaced people and animals, and caring for injured animals.
*World Central Kitchen: Providing meals to people in need by partnering with local organizations.
*Hawaii Lions Foundation: Matching up to $25,000 in donations for Maui disaster relief efforts.
Aloha BOH Bro’s
People who make statements on social media of not wanting tourist on Maui do not understand the economics of their statement.
Many had no skin in the game before the fire, no job, no debt, no mortgage, no car payment or payroll to meet. They don’t own businesses, pay taxes, annual permits or license fees.
They’d be the first ones to complain when Costco, Walmart, Target, Safeway etc. all closed for lack of business.
Individuals who survived the fire that worked in the customer service industry are going to need employment.
Owners of customer service businesses located in areas not affected by fire who’ve had staffing issues since covid will welcome these individuals with open arms.
It’s a fluid situation and you’re going to get some mixed signals, but don’t kill the golden goose that will rebuild and save Maui.
That’s tourist dollars……
Don’t think I could enjoy vacation with all those lives lost down the street. Just saying it’s pretty morbid. Was there any decision a government official made that was correct at any point?
So sorry for the Lahiana families whose homes and businesses were destroy or lost loved ones. They need time to grieve and renew their spirits. That said, the other local family and friends should be allowed to go help there Lahiana family or friends. I heard other family members who lived on the other side of the island were not allowed to come in to help their relatives. Better communication needs to be established to help the grieving families. Tourist should NOT be given more privileges over the Lahiana families. Maybe a specific time should be allotted to Lahiana family and friends to move freely in the area.
Although Tourism is the economic lifeline of Maui, they should be advised to act with understanding and compassion towards those affected by this great tragedy. The Lahiana people are hurting. Please be respectful and helpful.
Thank you for all your efforts on keeping us updated! I truly appreciate it.
I’m just as many other time share owners in Maui trying to make the best decision for the island and the residents there.
I do have reservations booked in west Maui towards end of October and I feel split on what’s the right decision at this time. I want to help besides donating money… maybe we can offer our assistance in other ways as well! Any and all thoughts would be appreciated.
It would be great if tourists are welcomed back, if the airlines would waive the bag fee for any packed bag/box filled with clothes, toiletries and other non perishable items that could be donated to displaced Maui residents.
Reality is that tourism is the economic engine that supports Maui (and the whole state). So yes, tourists need to return to the 85% of Maui that’s undamaged. Tourists can have a typical Hawai’i vacation and support the people and businesses who desperately need help. It’s a win-win.
This is a tough one. We live on the big island and had planned to travel to Maui for a couple of days for a change of scenery but given what happened we are postponing. I have a lot of friends on the island and they are still devastated and in shock. I do think that tourism needs to come back and as quick as it can however right now a message from the governor on Facebook saying to come back isn’t enough. We’ve already seen that the governor doesn’t have the information. We need to hear from the mayor who is boots on the ground. The island needs basic infrastructure back in place – cell service, water, and electricity. The island doesn’t need a bunch of Looky-loos coming to see the fire damage of Lahaina which will only impede the progress made to restore vital functions and deliver much needed supplies. unfortunately we cannot expect the tourists to take this into consideration.
State of Hawaii and Maui county need to open up ASAP to get the economy moving, and Maui will rebuild a beautiful front street!
With about 60,000+, or more, visitors/tourists on Maui on a given day, let them in where they can fit. The residents who need a place to stay, wonderful idea to house them at vacation properties. Using units for visitors not needed by those who need a place to stay it will be the visitors who will pay the bulk of the cost. We need to remember that the “government” is us, us taxpayers. So when the “government” pays, we pay.
I am all in favor of helping all those who had loses but there is a huge resource in tourist dollars to help fund what is needed. Tap into it!
We love Maui, the people and have been there on vacation 25-30 times. You don’t have to convince us to go! One of my vendors is having a large gathering in Wailea in December which I am silently begging them to not cancel. Anyone who feels the same should donate if you can and as much as you can.
We have reservations in West Maui for one month from today. We have not yet cancelled as it is not in the window where airlines or timeshare condos are automatically cancelling and in fact, the timeshare company will penalize us if we cancel. The Maui people are our Ohana and we are heartbroken with them. We spend 4 – 6 weeks in West Maui each year and we want to be there spending our money to help the Maui tourism if they want us. We know our favorite restaurants in Lahaina are gone but we are willing to travel to the other side of the island to help keep them open and the employees employed. If they want us there, we will come. #Mauistrong
500+ people incinerated. No warning despite a multi-million dollar warning system and the exact same weather conditions that sparked the hurricane Lane fire, from which the state and county officials learned nothing. Emotions will be fraught for a long time. Tourists will be an easy target of the anger, even though this has nothing to do with tourists. Like kicking the dog. “Please come but walk on egg shells and be highly respectful (or else)” is not a vacation. The whole situation is awful.
I picked my flight date to coincide with my mother’s (Rosemary) birthday. God rest her soul. She passed on mother’s day over 20 yrs ago. Maui (LaHaina ) was my home town for 5 yrs and it would have been a wonderful birthday present for her,to see me happy. I watched the fire on descent into Maui on my flight. Heart broken doesn’t convey the feeling.
Fire hydrants no water,hot power lines in high winds,no warning sirens ( even though they test them every 1st of each month). There certainly is alot of explaining to do (Mr.Green) rather than jumping on the climate bandwagon. Like it’s never been hot and windy on Maui before.Hmmmmmmmm
I’ve lived in Maui from 1969-1972 (Summers)Been bringing the family there since 1985. With many lifelong Maui residents as friends, I understand the needed protections for the island. As usual in every community, 80% are hard-working, caring law biding families. It’s this 20% that brings the visitor hate and claims Aloha stuff, but it’s just talk. Every city has these crazies.
Let’s not judge Maui, by this 20% and let them create fear in tourism.
It’s a give & take for all of us to help get things back to where they were. I’m coming back for Thanksgiving w/family to spend as much money as possible, helping the Maui economy.
Been to Lahaina many time I live in Australia I cried with you all I still can’t believe Lahaina has gone I pray the people of Lahaina can get through this I cried so I know how you feel sending lots of prayers
We have booked a vacation to Maui in the coming November. We feel and empathize with the people of Maui. However, we are torn between to cancel or still going to Maui. The travel information and comments out there are conflicting. We want to support Maui by bringing business, but on the other hand we don’t want to be a burden. A vacation seems so irrelevant in relation to all the lost lives and the challenges the people of Maui are having to deal with. I am struggling for an answer.
I saw a video today from Maui 24/7 stating central and south Maui are fine and need your stay. However to come and volunteer and help out where needed.
I am in the same situation, reservations for late November. We’ve been coming to Maui for 40 years and love the island and it’s people. So do we come to Kaanapali and support the island or cancel and come back at a future date? We’ll wait and see what happens over the upcoming weeks/months before deciding. Ultimately it might be up to the resort/airlines if they’ll allow us to cancel for a date that far out. Our prayers are with Maui.
Well said. I would be torn too. It’s probably best that the local government makes a decision and sticks with it. I agree that we need to be respectful and give the needed space and support in the short term, but after that, I think supporting Maui’s economy in a tasteful manner by traveling to the island is the best way forward. The timing has to be right.
As a very recent visitor of Maui, one of my first thoughts was to return in the future and support tourism for the island. However, I also questioned, “How soon is too soon?”. Considering the information we have so far, I think you should be okay to travel in November. Just like some of the locals have mentioned, you can definitely support other parts of the island. As long as you’re mindful of local residents and stick to other areas away from West Maui, you are supporting the island as a whole. I’m more worried about the hotels profiting off the locals.
Aloha…..I say, stay away from Maui out of respect for the people of Maui. Be reminded that a lot have lost a lot including family members, property etc. Ask yourself, what Would you do if you were in their place?
So, are there any levels of government from Maui County on up that aren’t currently decision-making via knee-jerk?
My first thought when they announced that they were asking all tourists to leave the island was that they were about to trash the local economy, but I also figured they probably knew more about the local infrastructure and what it could support than I do.
Maybe not.
There’s a lot of misinformation out there. Government officials were asking visitors to leave because power was out at West Maui hotels. There were fires in Kula that came close to some inns. And a fire in Kihei, although that wasn’t close to any of the resorts. There’s a concern that the hotels, timeshare units, B&B, etc. are needed for displaced local residents. But all residents need to keep working and the visitor industry employs many of them. Hotels in south Maui are open and not sold out.
BOH reported visitors who left Maui are crowding Waikiki, but I know of only two major hotels that were sold out this weekend. Not sure where that report came from.
Hi Alan.
Where did it come from? We were there. It was nuts in Honolulu and largely over the top as a result of those coming from Maui. There were no rental cars either.
Aloha.
On another site, I’ve received three private posts that were extremely nasty – even obscene and threatening – because I espoused the idea of continuing to support Maui tourism. I realize that visiting other islands contributes just as well to the State Relief Coffers as does visiting Maui but as Seth said in your post, taking away people’s jobs on Maui just does further damage to their lives and futures. Having said that, I’ve also been told by a friend that her cousins, who had lost family as has she, were threatened with their jobs if they didn’t show up to do hula at a local resort’s luau and when they at times cried, they were further threatened. So the conundrum continues.
That is just really sad for you to have experienced that. I have a feeling those folks have misplaced anger on behalf of the people of Maui and aren’t Maui residents themselves. In the case of the employer threatening the employees, the problem is the employer. They’re the selfish ones with no empathy. They should be exposed for their selfishness.