New Hawaii Route Shake-Up | Battle Brews as Airlines Defend Turf

A major shake-up may be unfolding in Hawaii air travel as airlines position themselves for dominance in light of the Alaska/Hawaiian tie-up. American Airlines has just reclaimed a key route after a five-year hiatus, while Alaska begins its moves to finalize the full integration of Hawaiian operations. That merger is reshaping competition for Hawaii flights, and with new nonstop service to the islands, major carriers are making strategic moves before the dust settles.

Airlines move to secure key Hawaii routes.

The timing of American Airlines’ return to Chicago – Honolulu flights is notable beyond just that route. United Airlines has held strong on this route for years, giving travelers a reliable, nonstop Hawaii flight from the Midwest. American Airlines stepping back in now could signal a broader effort to preempt future competition before it arrives. More on that below.

Alaska Airlines isn’t gathering dust regarding its changes, and while it has yet to announce any new widebody Hawaii flights beyond existing routes, that distinct possibility remains. The merger has given Alaska Airlines more flexibility, and it could eventually leverage Hawaiian’s aircraft and expertise to expand direct service between Hawaii and other major mainland hubs.

What this means for travelers.

For travelers heading to Hawaii from the Midwest, the immediate impact is more choice. American’s return brings a second nonstop option alongside United, providing more schedule flexibility and perhaps better prices, too. The airline plans to operate the route using a Boeing 787-8, offering a similar onboard experience to United’s 787-10 aircraft.

The competition could also lead to fare shifts. When airlines go head-to-head on a route, price adjustments that are favorable for travelers usually follow. With fares not yet loaded for this flight, it remains to be seen how much of an impact this will have.

BOH commenter Dottie and others had previously asked whether Hawaiian Airlines would ever offer flights to Chicago. Another traveler noted their experiences flying from Chicago to Hawaii using multiple airlines on the route, comparing a Southwest itinerary through Oakland with a nonstop first-class experience. Choices will continue evolving as airlines adjust their Hawaii strategies, including given this latest American reentry into this market.

The bigger airline battle over Hawaii.

This is about more than just one route. It is part of a broader struggle among major airlines to control market share in Hawaii. Suppose Alaska had been considering a move into this specific route between Chicago and Honolulu, as had long been rumored. In that case, American Airlines may have just cut off that opportunity at the pass.

United Airlines has long maintained dominance on long-haul Hawaii routes, with its well-established network from multiple mainland cities. It has faced competition before and adapted as new airlines entered the space. The airline remains a key player and will now have to compete more directly to retain passengers on this more than nine-hour route.

Despite stepping back from specific Hawaii routes in the past, American Airlines is making a calculated play here. Reentry into this market ensures it has a foothold before Hawaiian/Alaska’s long-term strategy takes shape.

Alaska Airlines is now busy fully integrating Hawaiian Airlines, and we are awaiting more news as it expands its own Hawaii strategy. Adding three more widebody aircraft this year strengthens its position somewhat, allowing for potential future expansions.

With Alaska already adding two new Seattle to Asia routes that are starting using Hawaiian planes, its recent moves indicate a willingness to grow in strategic areas.

What’s next for Hawaii routes?

This move makes it clear that other major airlines are not waiting to see how Alaska/Hawaiian Airlines evolves post-merger finalization. They are taking steps now to lock in desirable positions before the competitive landscape shifts further.

Alaska Airlines may have completed its acquisition of Hawaiian Airlines last year, but it is still integrating operations. While Alaska has served Hawaii with narrow-body aircraft for more than two decades, it now has Hawaiian’s widebody fleet of 20 planes to deploy, either adding more of them to key Honolulu routes or continuing to launch new flights from Seattle.

With airlines seeking to hold ground in Hawaii, more changes will be ahead while the battle for Hawaii flights intensifies. As more details emerge, we’ll see how these shifts affect Hawaii travel options and fares.

We welcome your input.