Only one Hawaii restaurant made the top 10 on Yelp’s list of the most romantic restaurants in America. That restaurant was Mama’s Fish House in Paia, Maui, which landed at number nine nationally just ahead of Valentine’s Day.
Yelp’s ranking is based on reviews by Yelp Elite members, with no more than 15 restaurants per state. Hawaii did not disappear from the ranking. Nine restaurants from the islands appeared in the top 100.
After Mama’s at number nine, the next Hawaii restaurant does not show up until #36. That was Signature Prime Steak and Seafood on the 36th floor of the Ala Moana Hotel in Honolulu.
What Yelp’s list reveals about Hawaii dining.
Hawaii markets itself relentlessly on romance. Sunset dinners, oceanfront tables, anniversaries, honeymoons, and once-in-a-lifetime meals are integral to how the islands are sold to visitors. With that framing, you would expect Hawaii restaurants to show up near the top of a national romance list in clusters. But instead, only Mama’s broke through in the top 10.
The rest followed much later, including By The Sea, House Without A Key, Michel’s at the Colony Surf, Noe at Ko Olina, Azure, Tidepools (Kauai), and Taormina Sicilian Cuisine. All are on Oahu except as noted.
Most of those are resort or hotel restaurants selling the view as #1. Mama’s is doing something else entirely.
Why this lines up with what we already found.
We reviewed Mama’s Fish House recently after years of driving past it, never stopping, and assuming it was living off its reputation. We paid full price, were treated like any other reservation, and nobody knew who we were. That is how we operate across restaurants, hotels, and airlines, and we’re mentioning that given some readers assume otherwise.
What stood out at Mama’s was how little of it felt like a performance. The restaurant sits beside a small beach cove, and the light across the water shifted naturally as dinner unfolded. Service followed the table rather than any pre-ordered playbook, and the room felt both elegant and relaxed at the same time. That is not how most high-end Hawaii dining experiences operate, and it helps explain why Mama’s landed where it did on this list.
The Valentine’s Day reality.
This ranking does not change the practical reality for visitors. Mama’s Fish House requires reservations months in advance, and a national top 10 label will only make that tougher. Most Valentine’s Day diners will need to end up choosing from the resort restaurants that dominate the rest of the list. There are tricks to getting into Mama’s, though, so please check the review for all of that.
Which Hawaii restaurant feels most romantic to you, and does this list reflect that, or did it miss the point entirely?
Photo Credit: © Beat of Hawaii at Kuau Cove at Mama’s Fish House on Maui.
Get Breaking Hawaii Travel News
We’ve been to Mama’s and were not impressed. Definitely not romantic. I agree with another commenter that Merriman’s in Kapalua is much more romantic. We also are big fans of Duke’s in Maui – beautiful open air restaurant that we find romantic enough and the food and service are always wonderful.
All in on Mama’s as a great Dining spot, and a place we’ve enjoyed since 1986 and our very first visit. To ‘Romantic’, though, I’m not seeing it, what of Merriman’s Kapalua, the former Kapalua Bay Club, that is perched high and open looking towards ‘Jaws’, I think an obvious omission,
My husband & I ate there 30 years ago. The Mai tais were fab & the food was,equally excellent but have not been there since due to the ridiculous reservation requirements. Probably won’t go back.
nice food, exspensive but most romantic? sorry but its not even romatic at all but still cool just not romantic. yelp needs to get their eyes checked. best romantic was in Italy back in the 1980s but not today.
We’ve dined at Mama’s on several times it is a unique experience. We arrive 15 to 20 minutes before our reservation. It’s the only restaurant that we dress all out for. We take several photos of ourselves on the beach there’s always couples willing to take photos of us as we do for them. We’ve met people from all over the world on that beach. Most on honeymoon, anniversary or birthday it’s a great vibe. The restaurant it’s self is pure Hawaiian magic. Service has always been great food is excellent, but I will have to say there’s a lot of excellent restaurants on Maui. Like anything else it’s all about attitude if you’re traveling on a tight budget then pass, but pass judgement on a place you’ve never dined at.
I wish there were a lot of excellent restaurants on Maui but there isn’t. Most are mediocre at best. They don’t have to be very good because they always have a fresh crop of customers that are convinced that they had a great meal because they are in Maul. If you actually live here you look forward to going to the mainland so you can enjoy a truly great meal.
We eat in 99% of the time not because we can’t afford to go out but because we have been disappointed so often with supposedly “great” restaurants. Mamas is in fact a wonderful restaurant! The only drawback is that they don’t have a dress code and very often now I notice that many diners are dressed in t-shirts and dumpy shorts, no respect
My husband & I ate there 30 years ago. The Mai tais were fab & the food was,equally excellent but have not been there since due to the ridiculous reservation requirements. Probably won’t go back.
We went once. One and done. Not worth the drive, the food, and especially the price. Service was no better than your local Chilis.
You’ve clearly never been to Mamas Fish House. The service is always to- notch. If you prefer chilis, knock yourself out.
“Only one Hawaii restaurant made the top 10 on Yelp’s list of the most romantic restaurants in America.” There are 50 states, so having even one in the top 10 is an accomplishment. And, 9 restaurants making the top 100 is also nothing to sneeze at.
Having said that, none of the restaurants look like anything I would find romantic. It looks like they have to have a high volume to make the list – the opposite of my definition of 💘
We have never been and probably never will. It is not even the money as much as the whole reservation hunt and the hype, which makes it feel like a restaurant theme park to me. If I have to plan a meal that far in advance, I would rather eat something simple and watch the sunset for free.
Agreed. Back in the 80’s, we used to pull up to Mamas after a long week of hard work and reward ourselves with a seat at the bar for a drink and some pu pu’s. Fast forward 35 years and it’s a very different experience (like everything). Since founders Doris and Floyd passed (wonderful people!) it has lost its local appeal. It’s a corporate production now that only caters 100% to high end tourist. The founders always made sure the local community had a chance for a seat at the table – that is now gone. Getting a spot at the bar now requires a check in at the Hostess station and a 20-minute wait, even if the bar is empty!
I am sure Mama’s is great, but I have zero interest at those prices. When a dinner out starts feeling like a payment, it kills the romance part for me.
A lot of dining here is overpriced and forgettable, especially when it is attached to a resort. Mama’s is overpriced too, but at least it is memorable, and that is the main difference.
We recently tried to book Mama’s for our anniversary and struck out, and I am sure this will just make it worse.
I have a love-hate relationship with Mama’s. The setting is incredible but the hype makes people act weird. If you go in expecting a quick sunset meal, or a reasonable price, you picked the wrong restaurant.
A lot of Hawaii’s resort dining is no soul and all view. Mama’s is expensive, but at least it does not feel like it is selling you a script.
I love Mama’s, but I also think it is fair to admit it is a splurge and not some hidden gem. We had a beautiful dinner and the service was excellent, but the bill was painful. I do not regret it, but we only do it once every few years.
We went to Mama’s once and I understood immediately why people plan a whole Maui trip around it. The place is not trying to act romantic, which is probably exactly why it feels romantic.