Every year, tens of thousands of Hawaii visitors make the same mistake: trying to visit too many islands in too little time. It sounds like a dream itinerary—volcanoes on the Big Island, waterfalls on Kauai, beaches everywhere. But what starts as a multi-island fantasy often turns into a logistical blur.
Savvy travelers are now rethinking this approach. They’re skipping the island-hopping circuit in favor of something much simpler—and, it turns out, something often far more rewarding.
Why that multi-island advice may no longer hold up.
For decades, travel guides and airline sites have pushed the idea that a real Hawaii trip means visiting more than one island. Hawaiian Airlines still says, “To really experience Hawaii, you should visit more than one island.” Travel + Leisure recommends four to five days per island, which adds up to quite an extended vacation.
This idea made more sense in another era. Flights were easier and faster with less rigmarole. Airports were less crowded. Security lines didn’t stretch through terminals. What once felt like a breezy island hop now feels more like a layover marathon.
Today’s reality is very different, and most visitors don’t find out until they’re already mid-trip.
What it really costs to hop.
Each island switch comes at a price: time, more than anything, money, and energy.
To move between islands, you must repack, check out, return your car, navigate TSA, board your flight, retrieve bags, rent another car, and check into your next hotel or vacation rental. Even with a short flight time, you’re likely losing 6 hours or more for each transfer.
Some interisland routes now require connections through Honolulu, even between outer islands. But if you look hard, you may still find some nonstops. Early morning flights may sound efficient, but they often mean waking up at 4 a.m. on what’s supposed to be a vacation. Add rental car hassles, bag fees, and more, and each hop becomes a hassle that can chip away directly at the quality of the experience.
The more you move, the less you experience. That’s the tradeoff nobody talks about upfront in travel marketing.
What real travelers wish they knew earlier.
In our comment threads, we’ve seen a clear shift. Visitors who once booked two or three islands a week are warning others to think twice.
Michelle wrote, “We tried to visit three islands in ten days and spent more time in airports than at the beach. Never again.”
Ben shared, “We thought we were being smart seeing both Maui and Big Island in one trip. But we barely scratched the surface of either.”
Erin, a repeat visitor, said, “We skipped Kauai on our first trip thinking we’d come back ‘next time.’ That was the right move. When we did return, we gave it a full week—and it was everything we hoped Hawaii would be.”
These stories echo a broader trend. Travelers are choosing depth of experience over breadth and discovering that it’s the better choice.
The upside of staying in one place.
One island doesn’t mean less. It might mean more of the right things.
Instead of repacking for the third time, you’re savoring a sunset mai tai. Instead of hunting for your next gate number, you’re spotting sea turtles from shore without needing to chase them down. Instead of planning every hour, you follow what the day gives you.
When you stay put, you can explore an island’s hidden corners, get to know local spots, and allow the weather to shift your plans without stress. You might meet a resident recommending a trail or a restaurant you hadn’t considered. Or stumble across a beach you have almost entirely to yourself.
You’re not chasing Hawaii. You’re actually in it.
Understanding the fear of missing out.
Hawaii’s islands are wildly different—and that’s part of what makes the decision hard. The Big Island is just that, big, and it has volcanoes and lava. Kauai has rainforests and amazing beaches. Maui has the road to Hana, Haleakala, and more incredible beaches. Oahu has Waikiki, and Honolulu is a fantastic city to explore, with smaller communities on the Windward and Leeward Coasts. No matter which one you pick, you’ll miss something else.
Many visitors feel this tension: If I don’t see it all now, will I regret it? If that’s really a big concern for you, it might indicate that NCL Pride of America is a good choice.
But the other approach is the opposite. No one sees “all” of Hawaii in one trip—because there is no such thing. What matters is whether you connect with the place you’re in, not how many times you change zip codes.
One experienced traveler told us: “I’ve been to Hawaii four times. I’ve only seen two islands. And I still feel like I’ve barely scratched the surface.”
When to consider a second island.
A second island can work well if your trip is 10 days or more, especially if the connection is short or direct. Some travelers also opt for a quick day trip by ferry from Maui to Lanai.
Just don’t underestimate the time loss. Avoid back-to-back travel days, and plan buffer time in case of weather or delays. Always end your trip on the island you’re flying home from—don’t gamble your return flight on an interisland hop that morning.
If your itinerary already feels rushed, adding more won’t fix it.
What savvy travelers know now.
Choosing one island doesn’t mean playing it safe. It means you’re giving yourself a chance to experience Hawaii on its terms, not through the lens of a checklist.
A week on the Big Island could mean stargazing from Mauna Kea, walking across lava flows, and watching the sky turn purple over the Kona coast. It might even mean watching a volcano erupt nowadays. A week on Kauai could bring waterfalls, canyon hikes, incredible beaches, and roadside fruit stands you’ll remember longer than any airport terminal. On Maui, it could be sunrise at Haleakala, snorkeling at Molokini, or long afternoons in Hana. On Oahu, it might mean hiking to Diamond Head, paying respects at Pearl Harbor, or spending a quiet evening watching surfers on the North Shore.
Savvy travelers know: Hawaii isn’t about how many islands you check off. It’s about how deeply you connect with one.
And if you do it right, that one island will be more than enough.
Get Breaking Hawaii Travel News
Take your time, enjoy every minute on the island you choose for this trip. Talk to the locals, eat local food, attend a local church, learn about the culture.
We have been going to Hawaii for almost 20 years. At first we spent our whole trip on one island. We now go to one island and treasure every minute
Hawaii is heaven on earth ❤️
For a one week trip? Absolutely! Island hopping on a short trip makes no sense.
But that said, I love island hopping. First, I find it accentuates what is unique about the islands. Leave one and land on another an hour later makes all of the subtle differences stand out.
The ride isn’t boring either. If you’ve never flown from Kona to Lihue and sat on the right side, or did the reverse from Lihue to Kona, you’ve not experienced something incredible. 50 minutes of an island tour.
There are things that can be done to simplify the travel. Pre-plan to get the reasonable time direct flight. Book early. Turo or a local car rental company is drop the car and go, no line. Same at the other end, pick up the car and go. Either option supports locals. TSA precheck shortens the line to 15 minutes.
” If you’ve never flown from Kona to Lihue and sat on the right side, or did the reverse from Lihue to Kona, you’ve not experienced something incredible. 50 minutes of an island tour.”
This is the first I’ve ever heard of this. Now you’ve got me wondering!
I’ve been to Hawaii 6 times now. I spend minimum a week an island. The only time I did a multi hop was between Maui & Hawaii, taking an 18 day holiday. I feel you need time as you say to get to know the place. Also it allows you time to explore ( beaches, markets, local recommended food stops, etc.).
Great advice and even more sage suggestions in the comments. I’ll only add one, as you all captured what I first experienced when working in Hawaii on business (from the mainland on about three trips, total, in the ’90s) and then in personal travel. I’ve also told scores of people not to do more than one island a week.
Here’s my caveat to one of the points mentioned in the story: be careful too about going to the top of Mauna Kea (or maybe even Haleakala) and then either doing deep water diving (probably scuba) or in reverse order, or even in some cases, flying, the next day. Not a good idea for your body. Instead, relax for a bit in between activities and enjoy the aloha spirit – while you can still find it (and afford it)!
I don’t island hop and don’t recommend it. Some people swear by it however, and to that I say to each his own. No judgment from me.
When planning my first Hawaiian vacation to Maui, I packed so much into those 7 nights and 8 days that it took a week to recover when I got home! In subsequent trips to the magical state of Hawaii, I’ve scheduled less and relaxed more. Of course it helps immensely that we did a ton those first two visits to Maui, but we’ve come to realize that while in Hawaii, doing nothing is doing something.
Lastly, growing up dirt poor, I am blessed to have gotten to a point in my life to where a single trip to Hawaii, which once was a farfetched fantasy, became a reoccurring reality. I pray for the same good fortune for the people of Hawaii.
Different people have different modes of getting to know a place, and that’s a good thing. I would reject any rules or guidelines for one’s first and perhaps only trip to Hawaii.
On our first visit, my husband and I explored all four major islands in three weeks, with about five days per island. That was a perfect pace for us. We knew in that time that we didn’t like Kauai or Oahu, and that the Big Island and Maui were most interesting for us. Hawaii was the 50th US state we visited, so we knew what appealed to us and didn’t, and how to “taste” a place in a short amount of time.
Other people might have a desire to explore every nook and cranny and historical or scenic site of each island, or to sit on the beach and soak up the sun and surf. That’s what works for them.
I think that most of the tourists that go to more than one island on their trip, are probably on their “once in a lifetime” trip that they saved up for, knowing that they will most likely never make it back. They want to see it all!
My wife and I have made 20 two week trips to the islands with our 21st coming in January when we first started out we would do one week on two different islands but have since come to realize that losing a half a day or more in travel is too valuable. What we do now is a one-week stay on one side of the island and another week somewhere else on the same island. For example we do Princeville &Poipu….. Waikiki & North Shore…… Kohala Coast & Hilo. Maui is the only Island we don’t relocate. We find that this truly allows us to embrace “Island time” And do all the things we want to do with hardly any travel.
We need a week to 10 days just to relax. That is why a 3 week minimum is our visit to Kauai. This year we did 4 weeks. We have air and car reserved for 4 weeks next January/February with another week and a half reserved if family decides to come. One week? Not nearly enough time and that’s without changing islands.
Heading to Kona tomorrow from Ohio. Only doing the big island. Inter Island flights too expensive. Last time, we spent more $ for 3 days in Oahu than we did for a week on the BI.
Other than Oahu that has the bus system the other islands demands some car rental or ride share service to and from the airport. Unfamiliar streets and roads can also add time and stress. Who really wants to spend hours in a car waiting in some traffic jam. All islands are known for something Oahu- the gathering place Kauai- the garden island etc. I guess this is why Oahu is so busy.
That would be a horror. You pick an island, hopefully choose a location you can use as base and explore. This tiktok picture mentality is awful. As long as you respect the local’s privacy and stay out of places tabu, there is so much to do on each island. I know lots of people that skip Oahu because to them it’s only Honolulu. And even around Honolulu there is lots to explore. And who knows, we might even invite you to join us or give some insider tips of places to see.
Fly 6-7 hours for one week of Aloha??! Never. Won’t do that on other vacations either. Need the first week just to shake off the jetlag. Then a second week (or second and third week if you’re lucky enough) to feel like you’ve been on a vacation. I get it, some don’t get the luxury of more than one week. Then take the NCL Hawaiian cruise if you want to see all islands in one week. A small taste of each island is better than none. A big dose of Maui is absolute Aloha bliss!
To do justice to any of the islands, ideally you’d need at least 2 weeks per. I know that this simply isn’t feasible for many travelers but a single week hopscotching across the islands is just going to exhaust and frustrate more than staying put on one and adjusting to “Hawaii Time”…
Best Regards