A $619 Hawaii winter vacation with flights and a Kauai beachfront hotel sure caught our attention. It was being promoted exactly like that, but when we clicked through to find out how to book, we landed on an invitation to join its paid travel club. We weren’t quite ready to pay for the privilege of looking at a vacation calendar.
So we tried something else. We searched for the hotel, three-night stay, and San Francisco flights mentioned in the advertisement. Before long, we found Great Value Vacations, the company actually selling the trip, with its own public booking calendar. When we checked, it showed numerous $619 departure dates across January, February and March, all visible without joining for the Travelzoo promotion.
Something felt familiar about all this. Back in February, we paid Travelzoo’s trial fee to investigate a $399 Waikiki vacation and initially couldn’t find the advertised price. Great Value Vacations turned out to be the operator then, too, and we subsequently updated that article when the $399 dates appeared.
What is included in the $619 Kauai vacation?
Great Value calls its package Beachfront Kauai Escape. It includes round-trip economy airfare from San Francisco and three nights at Kauai Shores Hotel in Kapaa. The advertised price assumes two travelers sharing a room, bringing the starting cost to $1,238 for both, with the usual $30-plus-tax nightly resort fee waived.
We looked more closely at the hotel, too. Kauai Shores is an older, motel-style property with updated rooms and pleasant beachfront grounds, rather than the resort some visitors might imagine. The overall review scores look good, but reading the negative reviews too revealed complaints about room conditions, maintenance, and noise. Management is also unusually active in responding to reviews, and those exchanges left us less inclined to rely on the high scores alone.
We’ve eaten at the adjacent Lava Lava Beach Club ourselves. The tables right on the sand are decidedly cute, but to us the food was more like Denny’s on the beach, with prices far above what it was worth. None of that necessarily makes the vacation a bad buy, although three nights leave only two full days on Kauai, and the rental car you’ll want isn’t included.
What the paid membership actually adds.
Travelzoo does identify Great Value Vacations on its public Top 20 overview, but the individual Kauai deal page doesn’t name the operator. Instead, the booking instructions direct nonmembers to a $50 annual membership fee with a $1 introductory offer for 30 days, which automatically renews unless canceled.
Travelzoo promotes exclusive deals and negotiated rates, but we found no published evidence that joining gets travelers a lower price or additional booking protection for this particular Kauai vacation.
We didn’t pay to complete identical bookings through both routes, so we can’t confirm that the final checkout totals would match. Travelzoo’s promotion has a December 4 booking deadline, and package prices can change in the meantime.
If you saw this $619 Kauai offer, would you pay to join the club or search for the actual seller first?
By Rob and Jeff, Beat of Hawaii.
Some of Hawaii’s most meaningful parts are the ones visitors walk right past without knowing they are there. We’ve spent nearly 20 years finding them firsthand for BOH as full-time Hawaii residents reporting on travel, culture, and island life, and telling you what they mean for your trip. Join us →
Get Breaking Hawaii Travel News






