Daring Move on Narrow-Body Hawaii Flights: Airline Tests 44 First Class Seats

Delta is experimenting with its Airbus A321neo, the Hawaii stalwart, in a way that stunned aviation watchers and could soon ripple across island routes. Thanks to a leak from JonNYC, one of the most reliable airline insiders, we now know about plans for a configuration with 44 first class seats. That is more than double what you’d typically expect on this narrowbody jet, and it puts Hawaii travelers squarely in the middle of the industry’s latest push toward trending premium.

How the A321neo redefined Hawaii flying.

The Airbus A321neo has changed Hawaii air travel as much, if not more, than any other single aircraft in the past decade. Hawaiian Airlines built much of its mainland service around it, replacing aging 767s with a plane that offered efficiency but less comfort. When we reviewed Hawaiian’s A321neo first class, we found a seat that felt okay for a hop to California but generally lacking on the six-hour overwater journey.

We’ve tried Delta A321neo first class to Hawaii and can report essentially the same results. American made similar moves, gradually shifting widebody routes onto the same A321neo. Flyers noticed.

The aircraft’s fuel savings may be undeniable, but the experience often leaves travelers nostalgic for the days of roomier jets and more generous layouts. One BOH reader put it bluntly: First class on the A321neo felt like economy with a bigger tray table.

Leaks of upcoming United and American A321XLR cabins point to narrow-body Hawaii flights with three cabins, including lie-flat suites and true premium economy. That raises the bar even further for what travelers will expect in the years ahead, and puts Delta’s 44-seat first class plan into a broader industry trend.

What reliable leak revealed.

The leak reveals a layout with a total of 164 seats: 44 in first class, 54 in Comfort+, and 66 in standard economy. Compare that to the standard Delta A321neo with 194 seats, including just 20 in first. Something unusual is going on here.

At this point, no flights are yet scheduled with the 44-seat layout, so for now it remains a plan rather than something passengers can book.

The explanation, according to JonNYC, is that Delta’s premium transcontinental A321neos are stuck in limbo. Those jets were supposed to feature lie-flat business class and premium economy, but certification delays have left them grounded. Rather than keep them parked, Delta is converting those premium sections into domestic-style first class and flying them as is.

This may be temporary, or not. But passengers boarding an A321neo with 44 first class seats will quickly form new expectations. If it works, Delta may not be in a hurry to revert anything at all.

The quick rise of premium seats on Hawaii routes.

Airlines have been shifting toward premium for years, and Hawaii has been one of the clearest test markets. Comfort+ rows, premium economy sections, and lie-flat first class have become the norm on long-haul flights. It’s all driven by loyalty programs and the revenue gap between standard and premium coach tickets.

Hawaiian Airlines illustrates the trend. Its A321neo first class never lived up to the hype, while its A330 lie-flat product aged into obsolescence. We once documented this in Stunned Hawaiian Airlines First Class Lie-Flat Review.

That also reflects just how much has changed. Alaska will soon be retrofitting its Hawaiian A330 fleet, as we covered in Hawaiian’s A330 Overhaul Could Drop 60 Economy Seats. What That Means for You.

Hawaiian has also relied on the A321neo for Hawaii. Its cabins have been smaller up front, but as we noted in Hawaii Flyers Watch Airline Cabins Leap Ahead: Will They Benefit?, the industry-wide push toward premium means Alaska will be forced to consider bigger front cabins too.

At the same time, leaks of United and American A321XLR layouts show three distinct cabins — lie-flat, premium economy, and standard economy, aimed directly at specific longer routes, some of which will include Hawaii. That also reinforces how quickly expectations are moving beyond simple recliner first class and extra-legroom economy.

Why Hawaii travelers miss widebody nostalgia and comfort.

The real sticking point is memory. Travelers recall when flying to Hawaii meant boarding a wide-body aircraft with two aisles, ample bathrooms, and well-balanced cabins. The A321neo largely eliminated that in the name of efficiency.

We’ve heard it countless times in reader comments: “It feels like we lost something.” A family that flew Hawaiian’s A321neo from Los Angeles told us they were shocked at how small the plane felt compared to the 767s of the past. Even in first class, they said, “it didn’t feel like Hawaii.”

That nostalgia shapes how passengers see Delta’s 44-seat plan. On paper, it looks generous. In practice, it may simply magnify the sense that airlines are jamming more “premium” in wherever they can, while economy shrinks further.

The risks of over-premiumization.

Forty-four first class seats on a 164-seat aircraft is an extreme ratio. It creates logistical and service headaches. Can flight attendants realistically provide a premium experience to nearly half the cabin? And if first class feels like economy with better drinks, does anyone really win?

For Hawaii travelers, already paying more for lodging, cars, and fees, the risk is alienation. Families may see first class out of reach, while economy becomes even less comfortable. That’s a recipe for frustration.

Could Alaska/Hawaiian follow suit?

It’s hard to imagine Alaska/Hawaiian ignoring this shift entirely. If Delta demonstrates that a bloated first class is financially viable, others may follow. That would mean larger premium cabins on the very A321neos that currently dominate Hawaii routes on three airlines.

But it’s also risky. Hawaiian has long marketed itself on service and a distinct sense of place. Flooding a narrowbody with first class seats risks diluting that identity even further. If the premium experiment fails, it could leave the airline stuck between two strategies: chasing high-end revenue while alienating the everyday Hawaii flyer who has kept it aloft for decades.

The bottom line.

Delta’s 44-seat A321neo is more than a quirky stopgap. It signals just how far airlines are willing to experiment in pushing the premium model, even on narrowbodies. For Hawaii, where the A321neo has already reshaped flying, this could be the next major turning point.

The real question is whether travelers see value in it. For some, more first class seats mean better chances at upgrades and mileage awards. For others, it’s yet another sign that the back of the plane is being hollowed out even more.

Would you pay extra for a Hawaii first class seat on a plane where nearly half the passengers are “premium”? Or does this feel like airlines pushing too hard on premium at the expense of the experience?

Photo Credit: Beat of Hawaii flying Delta.