Maui has great resorts and an improved airport with the most flights (including widebody) to Hawaii other than Honolulu. But now it has clearly become too much of a good thing. So what happens next?
Leave a Comment
306 thoughts on “Maui Visitors and Residents Square Off Starting Here”
The UK is an island with many more visitors than Maui. Popular tourist spots have a Park and Ride system.
Why not do improve your transit system with the money raised from parking? It’s great that Maui has coastal boardwalks in some areas so we can walk to places instead of driving.
I live in Washington, about a twenty minute drive from downtown Seattle and their famous Pike’s Place Market but I haven’t been there in well over five years because the last time I went, the parking was way too expensive. Additionally, I pay the same price to park at popular trailheads in our area that our out of state visitors do and I’m okay with that, even though it means that in summer months I have to arrive at the trailhead at 6:00 a.m. or earlier in order to snag a parking spot. I’m okay with all of that because the population of the Earth is going to continue to grow and add pressures to people who live in popular destinations, but I disagree with pricing anybody out of visiting my area or anywhere else they’d like to visit.
Maui seems like a tacky generic west coast suburb these days. Charge what you want, but I don’t think it’s fair in the US to discriminate the fare based on state of residence.
And a real holistic system would charge all and use the revenue to support shuttles and alternatives to the paid parking. Not make this another mystery tax.
$30 a day is ridiculous, during the pandemic Maui was talking about how to manage future tourism. Obviously, as usual Greed wins. We love Maui and have been coming here for more than 30 years, we are not rich by any means.
Another example of the loss of the Aloha spirit over money. So, so sad
To the dying Aloha spirit
Tom & Beth K
I own property and a car on Maui. However, being a Canadian citizen, I am only allowed to spend up to 6 months per year on island. As a part time resident my property taxes are roughly 3x higher than a full time resident, and I pay the same yearly fee for my vehicle license. Yet I do not qualify for free parking, this does not make sense to me. It is one thing to change $30 a day to someone on island for 1-2 weeks, and other for someone who is on island for 5-6 months a year. There should at least be a deeply discounted month/annual parking pass option for property owners.
All about me me me
I don’t have a problem with residents getting preference. For so many friends from here in the Northwest, when I mention Hawaii, they only think of Maui. As the Big Island is my favorite I’m ok with that. The Big Island does charge for parking at the favorite beaches, but not $30.
Obviously in violation of the Privileges and Immunities clause of the US Constitution
Not at all. Residents in most every state have such rules
Please say more about that.
Mahalo.
On our last trip ( aug-sept 2022 ) , parking was typical for all the hotspots , we don’t have a problem with paid parking like in Lahaina The problem we had was with all the ” closed ” signs & boarded up windows / doors of shops , staffing of eateries , poor food , the bums on every corner and just the overall run down feel / vibe of Lahaina and Paia.
For those of us who spend months on Maui,I recommend a monthly pass option. We have been spending a lot of time yearly for 20 years. $30 per day is ridiculous for timeshare owners who spend a lot while on the island already, including on real estate taxes. We are not casual tourists!
No tourists during the pandemic. Huge loss of money but locals were able to enjoy the islands the way they would like them to be. We get it.How about no more tourists allowed,then when the locals no longer have jobs and can’t pay for housing,they can move to all those free parking spots.
You were able to enjoy them during the pandemic because, and solely because of all the free money given out. If you didn’t get thst you wouldn’t have enjoyed it. At least admit that.
California has parking meters directly in front of our larger beautiful beaches that don’t discriminate between tourists and locals . Locals have to pay too! If you choose not to park here, there is plenty of free(on the street parking) for you.
After having recently spent 10 days with a rental car in Maui, I came to see how expensive it is to live there. The service industry people that support tourism drive a long way to get to their jobs, especially in luxury resorts such as those found in South Maui. Because beach conditions change over the course of the day, I would urge an hourly rate such as already in place at one of the marinas there. The residents deserve a perk like this.
Obviously you are a resident
the comment “what is another $30 to park”, we were in Maui last year and of the 14 days we went to the beach 10 times. That’s and extra $300. Plus the parking to visit Lahaina and other times we took boat excursions. That adds up to $400 or more per visit.
There has to be a better long term solution.
One thing I have not seen here is the ‘in and out privilege’ aspect of the $30/day beach parking. I go to the beach in the morning, leave around 1130, come back around 3:00 to 5:00 in the afternoon. Try to stay out of the mid-day sun. So, by doing this, do I get stuck with Two $30 charges? This could be a real bite for someone staying two weeks every year. Would cost more to park than it would to fly there! And, as many have noted, with the cost of food, a car and dining out, etc., the lure of the Islands begins to fade. But, have no fear local people; you will have the idyllic island lifestyle world (that most of you have never actually experienced) back again, just fewer jobs, less income, and wondering how to pay the rent/mortgag
That’s extrmely high cost for parking flat fee. Why not limit numbers of visitors on Maui if there’s not inrastructue, or would that be a source of income loss and concern for the greedy who want more and more money from visitors?
Limit the number of visitors? And how would you propose to do that? I would think, at a minimum, Hawaiian Airlines would have something to say about that.
Quit allowing more vacation rentals. If you build it they will come!
On Maui, vacation rentals can no longer be built, and the number of vacation rentals have been capped, so at least in Maui you don’t have to worry about “allowing more vacation rentals”. Doesn’t apply to hotels, though, they are exempt. They can build with abandon, as per latest legislation.
So maybe you can substitute “hotels” for “vacation rentals” in your protests.
😂🤣🌴
When we first purchased our timeshare in Maui (33 years ago) we were told there would be no more beachfront building 😅 and no building would be taller than a palm tree.
Obviously, that was not true. Money is the only driver and aloha is dying a slow death on Maui😢.
Have you seen the new Hilton timeshare on Kihei road, it’s huge and on a wonderful piece of property. Poorly planned (all they want is money). Note the excessive flooding on S. Kihei rd.
So, moral of the story, do not believe there will be no more building. The rich and greedy will build until there is nothing left of or aloha😥 we are so sad.
Tom and Beth
Don’t take us wrong, we love Maui and the people, but money rules everything
I’ve been going to a time share north of Kaanapali Beach resorts for over 25 years myself. It has few amenities, no beach, and it’s (mostly) quiet. I’ve watched the buildup on the open space in the area, like the massive Westin project next to one of my (used to be ) favorite beaches. Now you can’t find a spot on the sand. The $30 beach fee will cause those free beach access parking spots to disappear, and the hotels will just keep raking in those fat tourist dollars. One thing that really frosts me is, the hotels have a lower property tax rate than we timeshare holders! What’s wrong with this picture? Guess who has the political sway??? I don’t wonder.
Encourage All visitors to use resort sponsored buses/shuttles for their day at the beach. Encourage all visitors to utilize resort beaches.
Regarding the statement that “If one can afford to go to Hawaii,they can afford $30 a day to park.” This is not factual. The truth is, many people save for years to be able to go to Hawaii. Some push back needed home improvements, updating cars, doing without other things, just to get to Hawaii for a week or two. Not every visitor is wealthy. They may be putting their favorite guilty pleasure first, a Hawaiian vacation being that pleasure. I am one of those people. I speak of experience,that Hawaii has taken residence in my soul as it has for many Islanders and mainlanders. To read articles that do not portray the actual facts of most of your visitors, makes me sad. Please try to see both sides of this story.Thank you. We are not all rich.
Hi Ellen.
Thanks for your first comment. We did not say that; it was not an article. It was a comment from someone else.
Aloha.
Exactly where my wife and I are at. We give up a lot to be able to go to Hawaii. I think we have been priced out of the market. It’s too bad we love the place we’ve met lots of really nice people but will have to look elsewhere to get away from Canadian winter.
Try Bucerias Mexico–it’s a lot less expensive and the food is fantastic. A lot of Canadians spend the winter here.
Think about those of us who live here and have had our quality of life greatly impacted by tourism. Parking is the not the real issue here, it is the impact of tourism. If tourism levels were reduced by 50%, which is back to what it was 15 years ago, locals would not be complaining to the county council and parking would be free. They won’t do that because the hotels and restaurants would then complain, so they try bandaids like parking fees.
The Maui aloha is gone . Many years feeling aloha , it is now leave your money but not your foot print . Discrimination really is not ok . We spend 20-30k every time we go to Maui . No more . Please do without tourist money and find gainful employment in another way . This is our last trip , enjoy the space .
Government is the problem. How about a moratorium on construction in vacation rental zones. Fees, taxes, delays in airport improvements, etc. are attacking the problem from the wrong end. If you build it they will come!
Maui recently had a moratorium on short-term unit development, exactly as you suggest. The moratorium was passed, but could be lifted if a solution was agreed upon to help reduce overtourism. The county council’s solution was to cap short-term rentals at their current number, but make an exception for hotels. The net is that hotels are exempt from the caps, and they are free to obtain permits and build as needed.
Money talks, and the low-hanging fruit with no power and/or large lobby representation (I.e. the short-term rentals) are the losers.
Currently, the State of Hawaii has introduced bills to allow for the phasing out of short-term rentals (SB219 and HB84). If passed, short-term rentals throughout the state will be affected.
Many non-ultra-rich people who have been able to enjoy Maui by taking advantage of more reasonable short-term rental costs will no longer be able to visit Hawaii if the bills I described pass. I don’t know if you’ve checked lately, but hotel rates per night are upwards of $700-1000 a night.
If you care about this, there are council meetings on Monday, Feb. 13 and Tuesday, Feb 14 where you can testify. Here are the links:
HB-84: capitol.hawaii.gov/session/measure_indiv.aspx?billnumber=84&billtype=HB&year=2023
SB-219: capitol.hawaii.gov/session/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=219&year=2023
If tourist numbers dropped 50%, how many hotels, restaurants and shops would close and how many Maui residents would either be unemployed or have drastically lower income? Would the farms and ranches survive the loss of restaurant and grocery store income? What about the income of fisherman supplying those restaurants? How many civic employees like cops and garbagemen would you need with less visitors? I don’t think many Maui families would not lose substantial income. The largest part of the economy appears based on tourism. Less tourists,less work and money. More beach time if you have no money but is that really the desired trade?
Yes, that is the desired trade, and many in Hawaii are very clear about that.
Fortunately we can visit when qe want and you cant keep us out.
What Scott says is true to a point. It’s a ‘love-hate relationship’ the tourists and the locals have had for some time. Getting genie back in the bottle (the tourists) has its consequences. I you get rid of the tourists, you foster unemployment, but improve lifestyle. Populations are growing, both amongst the island residents (native and haole) and the rest of the world. You can’t change that, things are never going to be the same as they were 30-40 years ago. I know that as a visitor, starting in 1975. Locals are never going to get that ‘lounging on the beach with your ukelele and your sweet wahine by your side’ postcard lifestyle back. It’s sad, but a fact of life. I’m sorry for you, and for myself I miss ‘the old days’.
you could also say, “If you can afford to live on Maui, you can afford to pay for parking”. Only an entitled local would argue with that
Yes, and since the whole point of these fees is to reduce tourism, it is an empty argument. People won’t be able to, nor will they desire, to come to Hawaii if the fees make it unreasonable to come. And this is exactly the purpose of the fees.P
Thanks for the updates! I think this is hilarious. What will happen when they are overcrowded with residents who don’t pay. Maui is off my visit plans for the foreseeable future. Love the islands… the politics, not so much. Generally they offend while smiling at everyone.
After parking for free next to the Kona Farmers market and in the lot next to Uncle Billys Kona Bay Hotel for years i find both lots have been aquired by the company “Parkinq” and require $10 an hour parking. This can only result in more conjestion in the area as locals and employees and spend more time driving around looking for a place to park. This can have a negative effect on employees who are likey only making minium wage, and the efffect of less dollars being spent at local business like the farmers markets and small shops on Alii Dr. since locals will have less to spend due to legal ramifications subjected on locals from parking violations for parking without paying, to traffic grid lock and rising tempers.
Enjoy your new parking fees brought to you by your government
I agree with hourly parking. I think people would send less time and free up parking spaces. I also think parking isn’t the problem so much as tourist only economy. The island is only so big. What’s the capacity for the infrastructure? Limit fights, limit cars etc. build bike paths? Maui is so beautiful and every person I met there are so beautiful as well.
This is short sighted plan. Tourists will not happily fork over $30 US or$41 Canadian to sit on a beach and find the wind comes up an hour later and they have to leave. It won’t take long for them to decide to drop mom and the kids off at the beach and drive into the residential areas and park on the street and walk back. And people have a short memory. When the pandemic first hit, yes the beaches were empty and the water pristine, but many locals were out of work and had to leave the island. Tourism needs to be managed in a sustainable, comprehensive manner, not by playing whack-a mole as problems arise.
I have long wondered how long it would take until parking fees were implemented and why the environmental impact from the increased traffic hasn’t been an issue up to now. I feel shuttles and excursion buses available to all- not just the high end hotels-with alternating drop off and pick up times can be a definite assistance in this matter. Suggested flat fee is too high in my opinion.
Going to Maui today for the first time! Despite everything I have read in this site, we expect to have a wonderful time!
You will! Keep in mind the angry finger pointers opinions define them and their perspective on Maui, not Maui. If you go with the attitude you have you will have a great time, if you go trying to find fault you’ll find that. The choice is yours, sounds like you’ve made the right choice. Have fun!
When my wife and I visited Maui last week for our first experience on this island (we still consider Kauai our favorite!), we stayed around our resort in Kaanapali, which allowed us to park for free, and take numerous trips into Lahaina on the resort shuttle! No problem at all!