52 thoughts on “How High Is Too High? 1 Hotel Hanalei Bay Kauai Reopens.”
Ernie S.
It’s wonderful that they have spent the time and effort, not mention the money, to make this into their vision. The Price of the rooms and suites should have been expected with the considerable investment, maybe if we were to hit it big,after considerable taxes,it would become somewhat affordable to us. With the upscale decor and amenities one can only hope that a Highly Rated Chef and Cuisine will follow. There’s nothing that can spoil a stay like a “toxic” kitchen. I’m Certain that You will keep us up-to-date on this Amazing Hotel. Thanks BOH, You’re the Best!
I will not be staying at the Hanelai Bay. I don’t have that kind of money to spend on a hotel room. You can spend it on other things on you vacation such as food and tours. As a thrifty person (cheapskate)! I can’t see spending $200 or more a night on a room. I mentioned the Ilima hotel in another reply. It has the nice view, grocery store and restaurants close by, comfortable bed, a kitchen, a gym and pool. They have decent prices even with a resort fee added. They start at $115 and I believe the resort fee is about $40. That’s all I need in a hotel. I’m out a lot in the day sightseeing. A hotel is a place to sleep at night. I don’t need a lot of extra frills. Thanks for letting me share!
I see the garden view king room is $6406 which is enough for a week … then the ridiculous resort fees and taxes add $1605 for a grand total of $8011 . Most people of normal means would feel that the $1605 would be a more reasonable cost for a week but in this case $1605 is the greed of “additional” charges. While there is a market for upscale accommodations , there is a bigger market for reasonable priced places to stay … but reasonably priced in Hawaii is a thing of the past. I think many people will go elsewhere both because it is too expensive now and the uncomfortable feeling of being ripped off that ruins a holiday faster than being sick .
You didn’t mentioned the ongoing litigation by the terminated contractor. Who terminates a contractor at over 90 % complete? Never good for the project. And I don’t believe the project is completed yet? Be sure to but travel insurance if you book a prepaid room. I’m very suspicious of the claimed new (“latest”) opening date. The history of this project and the numerous claimed open dates are not good. We’ll see…
This resort, with the proposed process, wold seem to meet the new goals for Hawaii tourism. Reduced b=numbers of tourii with significantly increased costs f=so income remains high. A win-win for loudest voices.
When I walked by a couple months ago, the property didn’t look anywhere near ready. I believe they will be much later than February. Also, prices are absurd and will need to come down. Grand Hyatt is also way over priced at the moment, who is paying 1k+ per night?
I noticed that … someone is trying to make the blue collar type hard worker can not vacation in Hawaii. This is price gouging without a pandemic. They just want the rich over there. It really makes me sick. I know who will respond negatively will be the rich.
Good post by Nancy. Several of the locals on this site have recently commented that Hawaii desires “high-end” wealthy visitors. With the rates that this resort is proposing, maybe they are getting their wish. But then again, be careful what you wish for.
On my bicycle trip up the East Coast this summer, late one evening, a sub shop south of Boston tried to charge me almost $13 for a six-inch sub(turkey was it?). Thankfully it hadn’t been made yet. The price gouging is everywhere. “The new normal.”
Thanks for the update, BOH guys! I’m glad our last visit to the StR in 2016 was awesome as at those prices, we’ll never return to the property. I’m not sure 1Hotels can overcome what Starwood Hotels couldn’t: a 5-star view with 2.5 star service. Tough to staff a truly luxury resort in Kauai. Completely agree with you regarding the food under the StR name; worst meal I ever had in fine dining establishment was our 25th anniversary at the Kauai Grill there at the hotel! That being said, I’m sure they’ll have no problems booking the rooms; it’s the only hotel on the north shore. I’ll be on Kauai in March for a milestone birthday. We’ll be sure to stop by for a cocktail and check it out for ourselves.
The original Princeville hotel lobby was breathtaking. I’ll have to opt for skipping the hotel and check out the views from the Hanalei Pier, it’s breathtaking as well,,,
I agree that the original Princeville Resort was stunning—driving up to the main entrance & then walking into the lobby took my breath away. Too bad it’s had to go through so many—what I’ll call needless—iterations. I subscribe to the axiom that “if it’s not broken, don’t fix it.” I understand it my have needed some upgrades over the years, but I believe it lost an element of elegance when it became the St. Regis. More isn’t always better. And, I cannot believe the prices they’re charging for rooms. What a shame, but I’m so grateful I got to know Kauai in the 70s on through the 90s.
It’s wonderful that they have spent the time and effort, not mention the money, to make this into their vision. The Price of the rooms and suites should have been expected with the considerable investment, maybe if we were to hit it big,after considerable taxes,it would become somewhat affordable to us. With the upscale decor and amenities one can only hope that a Highly Rated Chef and Cuisine will follow. There’s nothing that can spoil a stay like a “toxic” kitchen. I’m Certain that You will keep us up-to-date on this Amazing Hotel. Thanks BOH, You’re the Best!
I will not be staying at the Hanelai Bay. I don’t have that kind of money to spend on a hotel room. You can spend it on other things on you vacation such as food and tours. As a thrifty person (cheapskate)! I can’t see spending $200 or more a night on a room. I mentioned the Ilima hotel in another reply. It has the nice view, grocery store and restaurants close by, comfortable bed, a kitchen, a gym and pool. They have decent prices even with a resort fee added. They start at $115 and I believe the resort fee is about $40. That’s all I need in a hotel. I’m out a lot in the day sightseeing. A hotel is a place to sleep at night. I don’t need a lot of extra frills. Thanks for letting me share!
I see the garden view king room is $6406 which is enough for a week … then the ridiculous resort fees and taxes add $1605 for a grand total of $8011 . Most people of normal means would feel that the $1605 would be a more reasonable cost for a week but in this case $1605 is the greed of “additional” charges. While there is a market for upscale accommodations , there is a bigger market for reasonable priced places to stay … but reasonably priced in Hawaii is a thing of the past. I think many people will go elsewhere both because it is too expensive now and the uncomfortable feeling of being ripped off that ruins a holiday faster than being sick .
Way over priced like most of Hawaii.
You didn’t mentioned the ongoing litigation by the terminated contractor. Who terminates a contractor at over 90 % complete? Never good for the project. And I don’t believe the project is completed yet? Be sure to but travel insurance if you book a prepaid room. I’m very suspicious of the claimed new (“latest”) opening date. The history of this project and the numerous claimed open dates are not good. We’ll see…
Who was the contractor? That is terrible they did that at 90% complete
This resort, with the proposed process, wold seem to meet the new goals for Hawaii tourism. Reduced b=numbers of tourii with significantly increased costs f=so income remains high. A win-win for loudest voices.
When I walked by a couple months ago, the property didn’t look anywhere near ready. I believe they will be much later than February. Also, prices are absurd and will need to come down. Grand Hyatt is also way over priced at the moment, who is paying 1k+ per night?
I noticed that … someone is trying to make the blue collar type hard worker can not vacation in Hawaii. This is price gouging without a pandemic. They just want the rich over there. It really makes me sick. I know who will respond negatively will be the rich.
Good post by Nancy. Several of the locals on this site have recently commented that Hawaii desires “high-end” wealthy visitors. With the rates that this resort is proposing, maybe they are getting their wish. But then again, be careful what you wish for.
On my bicycle trip up the East Coast this summer, late one evening, a sub shop south of Boston tried to charge me almost $13 for a six-inch sub(turkey was it?). Thankfully it hadn’t been made yet. The price gouging is everywhere. “The new normal.”
Thanks for the update, BOH guys! I’m glad our last visit to the StR in 2016 was awesome as at those prices, we’ll never return to the property. I’m not sure 1Hotels can overcome what Starwood Hotels couldn’t: a 5-star view with 2.5 star service. Tough to staff a truly luxury resort in Kauai. Completely agree with you regarding the food under the StR name; worst meal I ever had in fine dining establishment was our 25th anniversary at the Kauai Grill there at the hotel! That being said, I’m sure they’ll have no problems booking the rooms; it’s the only hotel on the north shore. I’ll be on Kauai in March for a milestone birthday. We’ll be sure to stop by for a cocktail and check it out for ourselves.
The original Princeville hotel lobby was breathtaking. I’ll have to opt for skipping the hotel and check out the views from the Hanalei Pier, it’s breathtaking as well,,,
I agree that the original Princeville Resort was stunning—driving up to the main entrance & then walking into the lobby took my breath away. Too bad it’s had to go through so many—what I’ll call needless—iterations. I subscribe to the axiom that “if it’s not broken, don’t fix it.” I understand it my have needed some upgrades over the years, but I believe it lost an element of elegance when it became the St. Regis. More isn’t always better. And, I cannot believe the prices they’re charging for rooms. What a shame, but I’m so grateful I got to know Kauai in the 70s on through the 90s.